The Fate of Stannis Baratheon in Game of Thrones: Analysis and Speculation

In the HBO series Game of Thrones, the character of Stannis Baratheon holds a significant place in the narrative, despite his tragic end. Despite numerous speculations, his death remains a pivotal moment that alters the course of the story. In this article, we will dive into the nuances of Stannis's character, the potential outcomes if he had survived, and the reasons for his demise as depicted in the show.

Stannis Baratheon: A Strategic Player

_Stannis Baratheon, the righteous and strategic king, emerges as a formidable player in the struggle for power in Westeros. Despite not being the heroic figure in the Azor Ahai legend, his tactical prowess and preparedness make him a force to be reckoned with. One could argue that he would have bested the Boltons but ultimately fell against the Others, a development that would have significantly impacted the series._

Survival vs. Demise: A Debate

The debate rages on whether Stannis Baratheon should have lived. Personally, I would have preferred his survival, not merely because it adds another layer of complexity to Brienne of Tarth's character and her moral dilemma, but also because it would have provided a more nuanced and satisfying conclusion to his storyline. However, the show must move forward, and his death serves a practical purpose in the broader narrative.

Brienne of Tarth and Stannis' Death

Brienne of Tarth's duty to Sansa Stark makes her decision to kill Stannis a moral choice. This decision reflects a deeper character arc for Brienne, who must navigate the complexities of loyalty and duty. Her statement, “Go on then do your duty,” suggests her internal conflict and the weight of the decision. Stannis's death, while mercifully resolved, allows the series to progress without undermining Brienne's moral integrity.

The Character's Deserts

Stannis's character is marked by numerous sacrifices and strategic decisions. However, his eventual death serves to maintain the integrity of the story's progression. His survival would have added unnecessary complications, such as the claim to the Iron Throne, and would have detracted from the focus on other critical plot points. The show's narrative demands that he falls in battle, ensuring that the story remains on track for its climactic resolution.

Speculative Scenes and Alternate Realities

Speculation often leads to vivid imagery, such as imagining Stannis wearing a pink suit and expressing his retirement, only to turn on those around him. While these scenes are entertaining, they detract from the story's overall pacing and thematic coherence. The show's decision to keep Stannis's death off-screen is a deliberate choice to preserve the character's dignity and the integrity of the narrative.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the death of Stannis Baratheon in Game of Thrones is a wise narrative choice that serves the broader plot and character development of the series. While his survival might have introduced new layers, the show's limited time frame and the need for a clear conclusion make his death a necessary and fitting ending. The character's legacy lives on through the various ways his absence shapes the destinies of others in Westeros.