The Faceless Villain: Why Morgoth Is Not Shown in 'The Lord of the Rings'

When fans of The Lord of the Rings ask why the main antagonist, Morgoth, is not shown in the films, they often suspect a deliberate decision by the filmmakers. In fact, the absence of Morgoth's face in the movies is a direct result of the creative choices made by the filmmakers. Let's delve into the story behind this decision and the role of Morgoth in Tolkien's works.

The Conflict Between Morgoth and Sauron

One of the main misunderstandings is the confusion between Morgoth and Sauron. While both are dark lords, they play different roles in Tolkien's universe. Sauron is the primary antagonist of The Lord of the Rings, while Morgoth is the first Dark Lord and was Sauron's master.

Morgoth's counterpart, Sauron, appears prominently in the films due to his significant role in the story. Sauron is the main villain in the Ring Trilogy, the personification of corruption and despair. However, Morgoth, who was exiled long before the events of The Lord of the Rings, is not as directly involved and thus is not shown.

The Ancestry and Influence of Morgoth

Morgoth, also known as Melkor, is a central figure in the Silmarillion, a book that predates and extends Tolkien's Middle-earth universe. He was one of the powerful Valar (angelic beings) who rebelled against the will of the Ainulords and was cast out of Arda, the inhabited world, to the Void. Despite his exile, Morgoth's influence permeates Middle-earth through his lieutenant, Sauron.

Aragorn, in his role as the heir to the Dúnedain royal line, does indeed mention Morgoth briefly during his storytelling to the Hobbits. He describes how Beren, in his quest for the Silmaril, was strengthened by the lessons of ancient heroes like Beren and Luthien. This allusion is just one way in which Tolkien's more expansive narrative hints at the influential and terrifying figure of Morgoth.

The Filmmaking Decision

The reason for not showing Morgoth's face in the films is both practical and symbolic. The decision was not made with the sole intention of avoiding panic among viewers, but rather to focus the narrative on Sauron and the direct threat he represents. The filmmakers knew that a full depiction of Morgoth could overshadow the main story and the character development of Sauron.

studio executives and producers agreed that, for professional and hygienic reasons, showing Morgoth's face was not necessary. This decision allowed the audience to project their own fears and the magnitude of the evil into Sauron, making the story more compelling and relatable.

Beyond the Books: The Meanings of Morgoth

While Morgoth is not featured in the movies, he remains a significant character in the broader Tolkien lore. Some fans have noted the symbolic connections between the name "Morgoth" and modern phenomena. For example, the name shares similarities with a species of tangerine known as Morgoth; tangerines named after the ancient evil entity. This serves as a reminder that good and evil endure in all forms and that the legacy of ancient legends can still influence everyday life.

Similarly, the name "Morgoth" can be used metaphorically in real life to symbolize an oppressive force or a person causing harm. In one anecdote, a person who committed a lesser offense might be made to sell baskets of Morgoth tangerines on the street as a form of punishment, highlighting how the name can carry a sense of moral judgment even in modern times.

Conclusion

The absence of Morgoth's face in The Lord of the Rings reflects a narrative choice that prioritizes the immediate threat of Sauron. However, his influence is felt throughout the story and in the broader world of Middle-earth. The name "Morgoth" itself holds a complex and multifaceted meaning, connecting ancient mythology with contemporary symbolism.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why isn't Morgoth shown in the movies?

Because his storyline and influence are best conveyed through other means, such as Sauron's actions and Aragorn's storytelling. This focus allows the narrative to be more engaging and directly threat-focused.

2. What's the difference between Morgoth and Sauron?

Morgoth is the first Dark Lord and the master of Sauron. While both are evil, Morgoth's role is more historical and symbolic, while Sauron is directly involved in the conflict of the Ring.

3. How is Morgoth depicted in Tolkien's works?

Morgoth is central in the Silmarillion but is only briefly mentioned in the cannon story of The Lord of the Rings. His influence is more felt through his lieutenant Sauron and the lessons told to the characters.