The Enigma of Star Trek: Which Current Series Represents the Best Quality?

As we navigate through the current landscape of Star Trek series, it's essential to recognize that quality is not merely defined by animation or comedy. So, which current Trek series represents the best quality and why?

Lower Decks: A True Successor?

One might argue that Star Trek: Lower Decks reigns supreme among the current crop of Trek series. Often dismissed as merely an animated show or a comedy, it actually delivers much more. This animated series feels like the true successor to the iconic TNG, DS9, and Voyager canon, as opposed to the more recent series that only loosely adhere to the Star Trek flavor. What sets Lower Decks apart is its faithful representation of the original series' vibe—true to the essence without the need for alien race reboots, tampering with timelines, or overfocusing on specific characters.

From a nostalgic perspective, as one of the few individuals who remember the first-run original series, it resonates deeply. There might even be similarities to what Gene Roddenberry might have appreciated, given the show's respectful nods to classic Star Trek elements. For instance, Lower Decks included images from the Star Trek Animated series in homage to Kirk and Spock, and even enlisted William Riker and Deanna Troi to appear in a future episode, signifying the series' dedication to maintaining authenticity.

Evaluating the Current Star Trek Series

Among the currently available series, Discovery, Picard, and Lower Decks, Picard emerges as the one with the highest quality, despite its modern reboot nature. It’s worth noting that this isn't about rooting for the underdog or Stalinist-era fundamentalism. Here’s why Picard stands out:

The Next Generation (TNG)

The Next Generation is a series that has proven its enduring quality. Despite numerous fans advocating for the Original Series (TOS) for its nostalgia value, TNG's standout episodes simply can't be ignored. TNG's production values are superior, not to mention its emotional depth and memorable occurrences. TOS, on the other hand, was only broadcast for three years, meaning it lacks the extensive episode count of TNG.

Deep Space Nine (DS9): A Complex Gem

Deep Space Nine (DS9) offers a rich tapestry of narratives and characters. Unlike TNG, DS9 is more serialized and less episodic, often delving into darker themes, making it a less mainstream choice. However, DS9 excels in creating complex characters with ambiguous motives. Kira, for instance, embodies the dual nature of a Bajoran, standing as a moral compass while also navigating her personal and professional dilemmas. Garrick, a character who remains enigmatic, challenges the audience to question allegiances. Quark's character is another intriguing element, showcasing a distinct sense of honor and integrity, yet his motives remain just as unclear. Odo, a security officer, operates independently, further complicating the line between the Federation and personal motives.

The Voyager Dilemma

Voyager, although featuring some memorable episodes, is riddled with weaker performances, plot holes, and confusing story arcs. The show struggles to maintain the consistency required for a high-quality ongoing series.

Enterprise: A Lackluster Performance

Enterprise, while trying to establish a new timeline, often falls short in engaging storytelling. Its episodes are frequently criticized for being emotionally unfulfilling and often boring.

Why Picard Stands Above the Rest

The success of Picard can be attributed to its ability to blend a unique blend of emotional depth, complex characters, and polished production values. Beyond the seamless integration of advanced technology and captivating narratives, the series also explores philosophical themes that resonate with audiences. Whether it's the character-driven moments or the deep space mysteries, Picard manages to captivate viewers on multiple levels.

Ultimately, Lower Decks captures the essence of Star Trek with its straightforward storytelling and true-to-form spirit. However, if we consider the more traditional and intricate narrative, Deep Space Nine and Picard stand out, each bringing their unique charm and depth to the table. Whether it's exploring the complexities of a dark and intricate plot or the high production values and emotional resonance, these series have their own merits and appeal.