The Dornish Spin-off Controversy: Would You Watch a Game of Thrones Prequel?

Would You Be Interested in Watching a Game of Thrones Spin-off Based on the Real History of Dorne?

There is a significant debate and excitement surrounding the possibility of a Game of Thrones (GoT) spin-off based on the intriguing history of the Dornish region. As a fan of the show and the universe of A Song of Ice and Fire, I am particularly interested in exploring the lore of Dorne and its legendary queen, Nymeria.

Exploring the Lore of Dorne

Dorne, a region in the southern desert of Westeros, is filled with unique and compelling lore. It offers a lot more to explore than what is often shown in the show. For instance, the rumoured 'water magic' and Nymeria’s history are just a few elements that pique my interest. However, since the show's reality is based on a fictional world, there is no real 'history' of Dorne. The series has barely scratched the surface of this fascinating setting.

Should the Spin-off Focus on Dorne?

The question of whether a spin-off should focus on Dorne specifically is one that warrants discussion. While there might be pieces of lore about other places and time periods that interest me, the focus on Dorne is highly anticipated. The suggestion of a 'history' of all of Westeros and Essos is appealing, but Dorne holds a special place in the hearts of many fans.

Desired Storylines and Characters

There are several key elements and characters that would make a Dorne spin-off a worthwhile experience. For instance, seeing Nymeria land and marry Mors Martell, and then proceed to conquer and unite Dorne through marriage to the greatest houses of the region, particularly the Red Princes, would be thrilling. However, there are also significant concerns about the quality of content that could be produced.

Concerns About the Spin-off Quality

The primary concerns revolve around the writers and creators of the show. Many fans, including myself, have lost faith in the current creative team, particularly the producers and writers of the show. The phrase 'crack-pot frat boys' is often used to describe the creative team behind a large portion of the show. This team has brought forth content like 'girl power,' 'bad pussy,' and unnecessary focus on a handful of bastards.

More specifically, the Dorne arc in the show was often criticized for its gratuitous and unsatisfying content. There is a strong belief that unless the current creative team is significantly overhauled or replaced, any spin-off would perpetuate the same problems. The visual design, costume, settings, and music composed by Ramin Djawadi are often praised, but the writing would need a complete overhaul.

Despite the reservations, a spin-off written by the original author, George R.R. Martin (GRRM), showcasing the history of Dorne would be a different story. GRRM's detailed world-building and rich character development are unparalleled, and his perspective on Dorne would undoubtedly add depth to the lore. However, this scenario seems highly unlikely given the current state of the show's production.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, while I am very interested in a spin-off exploring the history of Dorne, especially through the lens of Nymeria and the Red Princes, the quality of the content and the current creative team's influence create significant doubts. Unless the creators and writers undergo a major overhaul, any spin-off involving Dorne would likely fail to meet the expectations of the fan base. However, the possibility of a spin-off penned by GRRM would be a game-changer and would likely pique the interest of many fans.

Do you think a Dorne spin-off would be a worthwhile addition to the Game of Thrones universe? Share your thoughts in the comments below.