The Doctor Who Showrunners: Steven Moffat vs. Russell T Davies - Who's Ruining the Show?

Among the fans of Doctor Who, a long-standing and beloved British science fiction series, there has been significant debate and criticism directed at Steven Moffat, as the showrunner for the series from 2010 to 2017. Many fans argue that Moffat has undermined the quality of the show, leading to a variety of perceived shortcomings. This article explores the reasons behind these criticisms and the wider implications for the future of Doctor Who.

Complex Storytelling

One of the biggest points of contention is Moffat's complex storytelling. His intricate plots, often described as "timey-wimey," have been praised for their depth and richness by some fans. However, others find these narratives confusing and overly convoluted, making it difficult for them to follow the story.

Many criticize Moffat's focus on intricate plotlines, which they feel takes away from the opportunity for meaningful character development. Some argue that key characters, crucially the Doctor and his companions, do not receive the emotional depth or consistency they need to feel fully realized. This can detract from the overall enjoyment of the series for those who prioritize character growth.

Recurring Themes and Tropes

Moffat's frequent use of certain themes also comes under scrutiny. Themes such as the idea of the Orac and its impact on the series are revisited repeatedly, leading some fans to feel that these elements have become overused and less impactful over time.

This repetitive nature is compounded by the reliance on familiar tropes, which can lead to a sense of stagnation. However, it is important to note that these themes and tropes are not unique to Moffat, as previous showrunners, such as Russell T Davies, have also employed them. The key differences lie in the execution and the impact on the overall narrative and characters.

Gender and Representation Issues

Moffat's portrayal of female characters has also been a subject of controversy. Some fans believe that his writing can be problematic, particularly regarding the treatment of female companions. The reliance on certain tropes and the portrayal of female characters can be seen as outdated or offensive by some, leading to a sense of disrespect or alienation from the show.

Fan Expectations and Past Success

The success of Moffat's earlier work, such as the beloved and critically acclaimed episodes of the seventh and eighth series, has led to high expectations. Some fans feel that these expectations were not met during Moffat's tenure, resulting in a perception of the show's deteriorating quality.

It is worth noting that Moffat's predecessors, such as Russell T Davies, had their fair share of off-episode moments but did not attempt a complete retcon of the Doctor's backstory. This contrast highlights the differing approaches to storytelling and their corresponding impact on the show's narrative and fanbase.

Comparisons with Russell T Davies

Many fans compare Moffat's storytelling style to that of Russell T Davies, who had a more accessible and emotionally resonant approach. Fans of Davies' style often prefer the kind of storytelling that focuses on character development and emotional growth, rather than complex plot devices and timey-wimey narratives.

While Moffat's work has been criticized, it is important to recognize that he also has a significant fanbase who appreciate his contributions. Iconic episodes and the introduction of memorable characters, such as Clara Oswald and River Song, highlight the positive aspects of his tenure as showrunner.

Conclusion

Despite the criticisms, the feedback from fans indicates a diverse range of opinions and expectations within the Doctor Who fandom. The return of Doctor Who to BBC One, and the hope for a reboot under the direction of Christopher Martin and Russell T Davies, signifies a new chapter in the series.

For many fans, the future of Doctor Who rests not only on new storytelling but also on the ability to balance complex narratives with emotionally resonant character development. The debate over whether Steven Moffat or Russell T Davies "ruines" the show may continue, but the ultimate goal is to create a compelling and inclusive narrative that caters to the diverse tastes and expectations of the fanbase.

As the beloved Timelord continues his adventures, the journey to find the right balance between intricate storytelling and compelling character development remains a crucial aspect of the show's evolution.