The Difference Between a Protagonist and a Great One in Fiction Books

When we talk about protagonists in fiction books, what exactly distinguishes a protagonist from a truly great one? The answer often lies not in the outcome of the battle or the conclusive ending, but in the chaos and intensity that builds up to the climax.

What is a Protagonist?

A protagonist is the main character or hero of a story. They are the central figure, usually the one who drives the narrative forward. However, while many characters exhibit heroic traits, what sets a great protagonist apart is their unique journey, depth of character, and ability to evoke emotions.

Comparing Tyler Durden from Fight Club/Fight Club

To better understand the difference, let's take the character of Tyler Durden from the iconic book and film Fight Club. When we read or watch Fight Club, the story is not just about who wins the battle. It's also about the mindset and methods used to fight. The essence of Tyler Durden lies in the intensity of the battles he engenders. His fights are not just physical, but emotional and existential.

Why a Great Protagonist Fights Dirtier

A great protagonist, like Tyler Durden, fights "dirtier" because they don't just adhere to the conventional rules of the battle. They break the mold, challenge the status quo, and often push beyond the boundaries of what society deems acceptable. Their actions and methods are unpredictable, making the story more compelling and memorable.

The Role of Mayhem

The term "mayhem" becomes central here because it represents the chaos and unpredictability that a great protagonist introduces. In the climax, the protagonist's role is not to achieve a perfect, polished victory, but to create an upheaval, to shake things up, to break free from the mundane and expected. Tyler Durden, in his fight club, is a master of mayhem. He challenges, disrupts, and brings about a whirlwind of changes in the lives of the characters around him.

Why the Ending Matters Less

What about the ending? Many stories have tidy, conclusive endings that wrap everything up neatly. However, a great protagonist ensures that the impact of the story lingers long after the last page. The ending of Fight Club, for instance, is ambiguous and thought-provoking, allowing the reader to reflect on the journey and the lessons learned.

How to Create a Great Protagonist

To create a great protagonist, writers often need to focus on the journey, the complexity of their character, and the depth of their motivations. They should be flawed, relatable, and capable of inspiring both fear and admiration. A great protagonist is not just a hero; they are a catalyst for change, a disturber of peace, and a beacon for the potential within all of us to break free from the constraints of our lives.

Conclusion

In summary, the difference between a protagonist and a great one lies in the mayhem they create. While a protagonist focuses on winning a battle, a great one fights the dirtiest, creating chaos and unforeseeable outcomes. This unpredictable journey is what makes the story truly impactful and memorable. So, the next time you delve into a book, pay attention to the protagonist's methods and the impact they make. Are they fighting for a tidy ending, or are they creating a path that challenges everything?

Keywords: protagonist, great character, fictional protagonist, battle, mayhem