The Decline of Movie CGI Since Avatar: A Closer Look

The question of why movie CGI seems to have declined in quality since the release of Avatar is a complex one. Despite the rapid advancements in technology, the visual effects (VFX) industry has seen a shift that hasn't necessarily improved the quality of every shot, particularly in mainstream cinema. Let's delve into the nuances of this phenomenon and explore why the bar may have lowered in certain aspects, rather than overall quality declining.

Advancements in Technology

First and foremost, it's important to acknowledge that the actual technology used in CGI has seen remarkable improvements. Over the past decade, computing power has significantly increased, enabling Avatar and other films to push the boundaries of visual creativity and realism. CGI in modern films like Avengers: Endgame and Dune often surpasses what was possible in Avatar. The technology is more advanced and easier to use, making it accessible to a broader range of creators.

The Rise of Unskilled Artists

While the technology has grown more sophisticated, the rise of unskilled artists and the increasing prevalence of CGI have contributed to a perceived decline in quality. The ease of access to powerful software means that anyone can produce CGI, including those without the necessary training or expertise. This democratization of technology often results in a mixed bag of quality, where average shots are mixed with poorly done ones, and sometimes, the poorest quality shots can overshadow the overall visual experience.

The Death of the Signatory Shot

A significant factor in this perceived decline is the explosion of shots incorporating CGI. In the days of Avatar, a movie often featured fewer but more intricate and artfully crafted CGI shots. Today, it's not uncommon for a film to have hundreds of such shots, some of which may not hold up to the standard set by the best CGI from previous eras. The shift towards using CGI for everything has diluted the impact of the truly remarkable visual effects, often burying them in a sea of mediocre or poorly executed shots.

Cases of Mediocre CGI

Recent films like Wonder Woman 1984 and Geostationary have received criticism for their quality in CGI. While these films incorporate impressive VFX, they also contain numerous scenes where the CGI vocals or facial movements are less than convincing. The industry now relies on an overproduction of effects, leading to an oversaturation where notable visual moments are more easily overlooked. This overuse can result in a dilution of the impact and quality of the best visual effects, making it seem like the overall quality has declined.

Quality vs. Quantity

An important distinction to make is between the quality of individual shots and the overall quality of a movie's visual effects. The industry has moved towards a quantity-driven approach, with directors and studios pouring resources into producing a higher number of shots. While this has allowed for more expansive and immersive worlds, it has also led to a situation where not every shot is as polished or as memorable as it could be. The well-trained eye of a veteran VFX supervisor is often needed to ensure that even the most basic shots are executed to a high standard.

Finding the Golden Ratio

The real challenge lies in finding the right balance between quantity and quality. Producing a greater number of shots with excellent craftsmanship requires not only cutting-edge technology but also a nuanced understanding of when and where CGI is needed. Overuse can detract from the overall experience, making the best visuals harder to appreciate. Studios and VFX teams need to prioritize quality and ensure that every shot, regardless of whether it's CGI or not, meets the high standards set by the industry's best works.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the perceived decline of movie CGI since the release of Avatar is a multifaceted issue. While advancements in technology have surely improved the quality of VFX, the rise of unskilled artists and the overuse of CGI contribute to a situation where not every shot holds up to the standards set by the visionary works of the past. The industry needs to strike a balance between quantity and quality to ensure that the best visual moments remain front and center, leaving a lasting impression on audiences. The future of movie CGI lies in nurturing a commitment to excellence and a judicious approach to its use.