The Debate: EU/Legends vs. New Canon Lightsaber Colors

When it comes to Lightsaber colors, the debate rages on! Is it the EU/Legends system where the crystal determines the color, or the new-Canon bleeding crystal method, which imbues more in-world magic and mystery into the color scheme? Let's explore the pros and cons of both systems and why some fans favor one over the other.

Understanding the Crystal System

The color of a Lightsaber in the EU/Legends and Old Canon has always been determined by the properties of the crystal. Certain crystals have specific frequencies that create the blade color. For instance, a blue crystal is known to produce a blue blade, and this color is consistent for any user as long as the crystal is not tampered with.

).

The Dark Side of Artificial Crystals

Interestingly, some fans have a soft spot for the Sith who often wield imperfect synthetic or Dark Side-infected crystals, which can produce unique and sometimes unstable colors. The Force, which infuses these crystals, can indeed be explained by scientific principles, making the lightsaber color predictable and reproducible.

The New Canon and Its Advantages

While some fans remain loyal to the EU/Legends system, the new-Canon method offers a refreshing and more complex approach. In the new-Canon, the color bleeding effect is the result of damage to the crystal, which Sith deliberately inflict to attune the crystal to their unique energy. This process ensures that a crystal that produces a blue blade for one person will consistently produce a blue blade for the same user, unless intentionally altered.

The main advantage of the new-Canon method is its break from the old rank-based color assignment. Gone are the days of predefined colors for specific Jedi ranks or levels of proficiency. This change addresses a longstanding issue in the lore, as the color of a lightsaber only activates at the moment of a combat engagement. Revealing a Jedi's color before a fight offers too much information for an enemy to exploit.

A Rite of Passage for the Jedi

Another compelling aspect of the new-Canon is the idea of obtaining a unique, rare crystal through a rite of passage. This crystal becomes a lifelong companion for the Jedi, and every lightsaber must be made to the individual's unique specifications, rather than being mass-produced from a color-coded inventory. This approach aligns better with the idea of individualism and the rarity of lightsabers in a galaxy far, far away.

Moreover, the bleeding effect introduces a layer of unpredictability and danger with each use, as the crystals can degrade or shift in color due to the intense emotional and physical exertion of the user. This aligns well with the dark and complex nature of the Sith and the unpredictable and variable nature of the Force.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

While both systems have their merits, the new-Canon method offers a more compelling and nuanced approach to lightsaber color determination. It incorporates the emotional and physical elements that come with using a Lightsaber, making them more than just a mere tool but a powerful symbol of the user's connection to the Force and their own struggles and journey.

Ultimately, the choice of which system to favor comes down to personal preference and the lore aspect that resonates more strongly with the fan. Whether you prefer the scientific and predictable EU/Legends system or the mystical and evolving new-Canon method, both offer unique insights into the rich and complex world of Star Wars.