The Debate: Clay Jensen vs Justin Foley in 13 Reasons Why

The hit series 13 Reasons Why has sparked numerous debates among viewers, with one of the most intriguing being the question of who is better, Clay Jensen or Justin Foley. Both characters endure intense challenges and make difficult choices, yet their decisions shape the narrative in vastly different ways. This article aims to explore the strengths and weaknesses of both characters and form a well-rounded conclusion.

Clay Jensen: A Complex Figure

Clay Jensen is a student at Liberty High School, admired for his honesty and willingness to face difficult truths, though he struggles with the pain he feels over Hannah Baker's death. Throughout the series, he takes responsibility for his actions, even facing harsh consequences for his role in the events that led to her suicide. Clay's character development is notable, as he moves from being an innocent bystander to someone who takes action and challenges the status quo.

Clay's vulnerability and emotional struggles are well-represented, making him a relatable character. However, some might argue that his decision to take a picture of Tyler without his consent showcases his hypocrisy, especially when considering the similar circumstances of when he took a picture of Hannah without her knowledge. This action, although it happened in the past, contributes to the portrayal of Clay as a flawed but ultimately redeemable character.

Justin Foley: Redemption and Loyalty

Justin Foley, on the other hand, initially does not seem to be the poster child for moral virtue. He is associated with the bullying behavior of the jocks and his role in forwarding the racy picture of Hannah to the students is a testament to his complicity. However, season 4 of the series reveals a different side to Justin. He demonstrates integrity by choosing to stand up against his friends and the school administration, despite the potential consequences.

Justin's decision to go against Bryce and his peers highlights his growth and transformation. Over time, he is portrayed as a character who puts others before himself, embodying themes of loyalty, bravery, and integrity. While his initial actions may be questionable, his subsequent behavior in the later seasons shows a commitment to justice and doing what is right, even in the face of adversity.

Comparing Clay Jensen and Justin Foley

The question of who is better between Clay Jensen and Justin Foley is subjective and depends on one's perspective. Clay's raw emotions and willingness to pay the price for his actions make him a compelling and relatable character. He faces significant challenges and makes difficult decisions, which often attract sympathy from the audience. However, his past actions, such as taking a picture of Tyler without consent, can be seen as hypocritical given Hannah's similar situation.

Justin, while initially appearing to be a dark character, undergoes a significant transformation. His loyalty, kindness, and willingness to take a stand for what is right make him a more positive character in the latter part of the series. His redemption narrative is particularly compelling, as it shows that even individuals who make mistakes can change and become better people over time.

Both Clay and Justin offer different takes on the challenges faced by teenagers in today's world, with Clay dealing with the aftermath of past actions and Justin overcoming initial flaws to become a more virtuous individual. Ultimately, whether Clay or Justin is "better" is a matter of personal opinion and can vary based on the values one prioritizes in a character.

Conclusion

The debate between Clay Jensen and Justin Foley is not just about which character is more virtuous, but about their journeys and the lessons they teach. Clay's character is a reminder of the importance of facing one's past mistakes and turning them into opportunities for growth. Justin's journey showcases the possibility of redemption and the power of making ethical choices, regardless of the circumstances.

Final Thoughts

While opinions on which character is more "better" may differ, one thing is clear: both Clay and Justin offer valuable insights into the complex world of teenagers and the struggles they face. Their stories highlight the importance of taking responsibility for one's actions and the potential for positive change, even in the face of significant challenges.

Which character do you find more compelling? Share your thoughts in the comments below.