The Critique of The Last Jedi: A Deep Dive into its Writing Flaws

Introduction

The The Last Jedi faced a significant backlash from fans and critics alike. While the film aimed to explore deeper themes and subvert traditional storytelling expectations, its execution left many viewers disappointed. This article delves into the writing flaws that contributed to the film's critical reception, examining how these issues impacted fan engagement and the overall narrative.

Subversion of Expectations: Ruffling Feathers

One of the primary reasons for the controversy surrounding The Last Jedi is its subversion of established story expectations. Fans had come to expect a certain narrative arc, particularly involving characters such as Rey, Luke Skywalker, and Kylo Ren. However, the film deviated significantly from these preconceptions, leading to a mixed reception among audiences. Some appreciated the complexity and departure from the familiar, while others felt the film betrayed the character personas.

Character Development: Polarizing Portrayals

The character development in The Last Jedi was another point of contention. Luke Skywalker's portrayal, in particular, was met with polarized reactions. The character was depicted as disillusioned and reluctant to train Rey, a stark contrast to his heroic persona in the original trilogy. This nuanced characterization satisfied some viewers' desire for a more complex and multifaceted character, while others felt it undermined the beloved figure.

Pacing and Structure: A Divisive Approach

The pacing and narrative structure of The Last Jedi prompted significant discussion. Some critics argued that secondary subplots, such as the mission to Canto Bight involving Finn and Rose, detracted from the main storyline. However, others contended that these elements enriched the Star Wars universe, providing depth and context. The film's structured narrative left some feeling frustrated by its lack of cohesion, while others celebrated its complexity.

Humor and Tone: A Mismatched Approach

The film's approach to humor and tone was another flashpoint. Some viewers appreciated the use of satire and wit, particularly in certain character interactions. However, the humor's timing and relevance were debated. Critics noted that the film's attempts to provide levity sometimes felt out of place and detracted from the overall experience.

Themes and Messages: A Complex Narrative

The Last Jedi delved into themes of failure, redemption, and the complexity of good versus evil. While these themes resonated with some viewers, others felt that the narrative's exploration of these ideas compromised the clarity of the moral dichotomy established in previous films. This ambiguity left many fans confused about character motivations and the overarching narrative.

Expectations from the Franchise: A Mixed Legacy

As part of the Star Wars franchise, The Last Jedi carried a significant burden of expectations. The film aimed to honor the legacy while also pushing new boundaries. However, its writing flaws often overshadowed these intentions. Critics argue that the film grappled with a narrative that tried too hard to be different, sometimes in ways that did not align with the established character models and motivations.

The Writing Flaws: Analyzing the Faux Fanbase

The primary writing flaws in The Last Jedi stem from a desire to cater to a more diverse audience. This approach led to heavy-handed subversions and shifts in established lore. For instance, Luke Skywalker running away is a deviation from the established franchise. Similarly, Rey's character development felt rushed and unexplained. Her abrupt abilities with the Force lacked the necessary exposition. The scenes in Canto Bight, meant to serve as a political message, were overly specific and detracted from the narrative's coherence.

Conclusion

The critical reception of The Last Jedi highlights the importance of cohesive and well-executed storytelling. While the film aimed to introduce new layers and complexities, its writing flaws often undermined these efforts. Understanding these flaws is crucial for the future development of storytelling within the Star Wars universe and beyond.