The Complex Dynamics: TChalla’s Stance on the Sokovia Accords in Captain America: Civil War

At first glance, TChalla seems to have played a significant role in the creation of the Sokovia Accords in Captain America: Civil War. This piece delves into the intricate nuances of TChalla's position, questioning whether he truly approved the Accords from a personal standpoint. Through an analysis of TChalla's actions and decisions during and after the film, we will explore the complex dynamics surrounding the Accords in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Introduction to the Sokovia Accords

The Sokovia Accords were a set of United Nations policies designed to hold superhuman beings accountable for their actions. They were instrumental in the conflict between Captain America and Iron Man, with TChalla and his father, King T'Chaka, playing a significant role in their formation. T'Chaka and TChalla were indeed instrumental in drafting these accords, with the former imposing them on the Avengers, believing it was a way to balance power and protect civilians.

TChalla's Role in the Accords

Despite TChalla's involvement in the Accords, it can be argued that he never fully intended to follow them himself. This nuanced perspective is supported by several actions and decisions TChalla made post-Accords introduction. For example, TChalla:

Continued a public chase and fight against Klawe, demonstrating a resistance to the restrictive measures the Accords imposed. Hid Bucky Barnes and helped restore his mental state, ensuring the Black Widow's partner was safe and cared for, actions that were not in compliance with the Accords' stipulations. Hosted a hero welcome party in Wakanda for the Black Order and Thanos, showcasing his commitment to the safety and well-being of his allies, even if they had not signed the Accords.

Additionally, it is notable that TChalla hosted a reunion for heroes who were essentially world-wide fugitives, none of whom had signed the Accords. This gesture further underscores TChalla's divergent stance from the restrictive measures of the Sokovia Accords.

Realistic Implications and Oversights

The realistic introduction of the Accords by both TChalla and his father, coupled with the United States signing the Accords, was a panicked and misplaced decision. The Accords were a response to the Tesseract and the subsequent events that followed, with SHIELD taking the blame. Furthermore, the US's decision to send a nuclear weapon to a highly populated New York City, despite Iron Man's efforts to protect civilians, highlights the limitations and misuses of the Accords.

It is important to note that the Accords would not have deterred Aldrich Kroff (Vanko) or Malekeith, as both were driven by personal vendettas and not bound by the Accords' terms. Thor, with his sense of responsibility, believed the Accords were more of a burden than a solution, especially since no one else, including Midgard, was willing to take on the responsibility.

Hydra’s Role and the Accords

The Accords' primary purpose was to address the feelings of powerless ordinary citizens after the extraterrestrial threat posed by the Chitauri and Thanos. However, by implementing the Accords, the possibility of making it easier for Hydra to exploit fears and resistance within the general population became real. This suggests that the Accords, while well-intentioned, were not a silver bullet and posed more harm than good in some aspects.

It is clear that TChalla, while supportive of the Accords in principle, did not approve of the underlying political agendas. His actions after the Accords were introduced show a commitment to his people and allies, rather than a strict adherence to the restrictive measures.

Conclusion

Through a nuanced examination of TChalla's role in the Accords and his actions post-introduction, it becomes evident that TChalla’s true intentions were not to fully embrace the Accords, which were inherently flawed and misused. TChalla’s actions continue to reflect a commitment to justice, safety, and the wellbeing of his allies, regardless of the terms set forth by the Sokovia Accords.

Some key takeaways from this analysis include:

The complex and multifaceted nature of TChalla's stance on the Accords. The Accords being a reactive response to a crisis that contributed to their limitations in practice. The potential for the Accords to exacerbate issues rather than solve them, particularly in the context of global security and accountability.

The Sokovia Accords, as portrayed in Captain America: Civil War, are a compelling example of the challenges in aligning with international policies and the impact they can have on real-world dynamics.