The Climate of Cinema: Why Climate Stories Are Missing in Films

Is the lack of climate stories in films due to a backlash against perceived political messaging, as exemplified by criticism of Disney's stance on climate change? This article explores the complex relationship between climate and cinema, examining why climate narratives are so rarely depicted in mainstream films.

The Rubber Meets the Road

People who are skeptical of climate change and its rapid impacts are unlikely to seek out films that preach to them. On the other hand, those who believe in the urgency of addressing climate issues might prefer a break from these heavy themes. For them, a narrative that offers escapism is often more appealing.

Moreover, many films that do deal with climate change have not aged well. Take, for example, the mockbuster film Titanic II by the Asylum, where a billionaire constructs a replica of the Titanic that sinks due to an iceberg explicitly caused by climate change. This film not only gets the science wrong but also fails to engage audiences with any meaningful climate message.

Climate as a Genre Excuse

Climate change can be a convenient plot device when writing films, especially for those with smaller budgets. It allows filmmakers to create bizarre or unexpected scenarios. For instance, the Sharknado films capitalize on climate change to introduce massive and implausible natural disasters. Similarly, Prey, a TV show starring Debra Messing, uses climate change as a catalyst for new psychic serial killers to evolve.

These films might not be scientifically accurate or educational, but they do contribute to the discourse on climate change in pop culture. In fact, climate change is one of the least controversial elements that can be incorporated into a film. A majority of Americans (75%) believe climate change is real, and 66% are concerned about it. However, higher-budget, mainstream films tend to avoid climate change stories because it often serves as the inciting incident for the plot.

Realism vs. Escapism

While climate change can be leveraged to drive the narrative, it can sometimes feel like a forced plot device that detracts from the storytelling. Many filmmakers prefer to focus on other aspects of the story that do not require such a heavy and topical issue to drive the plot. For example, a film about personal relationships, adventure, or mystery might not find it necessary to center its story around climate change, which could be perceived as politically charged.

A Growing Trend

However, there is a growing trend of films that address climate change more seriously and responsibly. These films use their platforms to raise awareness about environmental issues without resorting to melodrama or sensationalism. Filmmakers who choose to include climate change in their narratives do so because they believe it is a critical issue that needs to be addressed, and they are willing to withstand the backlash that comes with it.

Recent examples like The Long Goodbye, which explores the unintended consequences of environmental policies, and The Sixth Extinction, which delves into the impact of climate change on biodiversity, showcase a more nuanced and thoughtful approach to climate storytelling. These films not only entertain but also educate and inspire audiences to take action.

Conclusion

The lack of climate stories in films is a multifaceted issue. It is influenced by the desire for escapism, the complexity of climate-related narratives, and the backlash against perceived political messaging. However, there are filmmakers who recognize the importance of addressing climate change in their work, aiming to educate and inspire change while navigating these challenges.