The Blackfish's Independence and why He was Never Married

Does Brynden Tully, known as the Blackfish, remain unmarried despite his noble title and Great House upbringing? This article explores the reasons behind his solitary status through a combination of personal convictions, societal context, and historical context.

Personal Preference for Independence and Freedom

As a character deeply rooted in George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series, the Blackfish, Brynden Tully, is portrayed as a person who values his independence and deep sense of freedom. Unlike many of his peers who are bound to the traditional expectations of marriage and family, the Blackfish's identity is not solely rooted in these conventions. His preference for his own path is evident in his unwavering commitment to his duties and his unshakeable belief in personal choice over societal norms.

A Devotion to Duty and Responsibilities

The Blackfish's primary focus is on his family and the Tully legacy. His identity as a skilled warrior and his devotion to his responsibilities, especially during the tumultuous events of the War of the Five Kings, take precedence over seeking a personal life. His unwavering commitment to his family and duties is a significant factor that influences his solitary life. The historical backdrop of this era, where political marriages are common, further emphasizes the Blackfish's deviation from these norms, making his dedication to his family and his identity all the more poignant.

Reputation and Societal Context

His reputation as a fierce and honorable warrior adds another layer to his decision to remain unmarried. The Tullys of Riverrun are known for their straightforward, no-nonsense approach to matters of honor and valor. Brynden's reputation only strengthens this perception. In a society where alliances are formed through marriage to ensure political stability, Brynden's unconventional stance makes it difficult for him to find a suitable match. His independent nature, driven by his strong sense of identity, further isolates him from the expectations of a traditional noble family.

Disagreement with Two Main Theories

There are two main theories that suggest alternative reasons for the Blackfish's marital status that I find less convincing. The first is that he is gay. While some might find this appealing, it is important to note that marriage in Westeros is more about political alliances and status rather than love. Brynden would likely still marry based on practical considerations rather than personal preference. The second theory suggests that he is the father of Catelyn, Lysa, and Edmure. This is based on his close bond with these children, but again, this is not a compelling argument as marriage is not decided by personal affection.

The Third Theory: The Rejection of Loyal Houses

The third theory, however, gains more traction when we consider his past relationships and offers. Brynden refused proposals from the Houses Redwyne, Bracken, and Frey, all of which have familial ties to the Blackfyre faction. The Redwyne, for instance, might have had connections to the Targaryens via House Targaryen's alliance through the Redwyne family, while the Brackens, being sworn enemies of Bloodraven, would have represented a political hurdle. The Freys, having betrayed the Blackfyres, would have further complicated any potential political alliances for the Blackfish.

Conclusion

The Blackfish remains unmarried due to a combination of personal convictions, the societal context of his time, and his devotion to the Tully legacy. His independence and commitment to his duties, coupled with the historical challenges faced by noble families in Westeros, contribute to his unique position in the world of Westeros. While some might propose alternative explanations, the Blackfish's status as an unmarried man remains a testament to his strength of character and his defiance of societal norms.