The Best Hamlet Film Adaptation and Why

The question of which Hamlet film adaptation is considered the best among the many cinematic interpretations of William Shakespeare's legendary tragedy is a matter of individual taste. However, several films stand out for their unique interpretations and artistic merits. Let's explore the most highly regarded adaptations and the reasons behind their acclaim.

Why "Is Considered" By Whom?

The phrase "is considered" implies a lack of consensus on matters of aesthetic value, a rare occurrence in itself. Opinions on which Hamlet film is the best are often highly subjective, reflecting personal preferences and interpretations. Different viewers and critics might prioritize different aspects, such as the faithfulness to the original text, the acting performances, or the general direction and underlying themes.

Why Olivier's 1948 Adaptation?

For many, Laurence Olivier's 1948 film adaptation of Hamlet is a standout. This film is notable for its deft handling of the text, with Significant portions cut to enhance the pacing and thematic focus. Olivier's interpretation, while somewhat Freudian in approach, offers a compelling notion that the play is about a man struggling with decision-making. The black and white cinematography is beautiful, and Olivier's performance is of the highest caliber.

Why Not Gielgud's 1971 Adaptation?

It is indeed a pity that John Gielgud's Hamlet, famous for its exceptional stage performances, was never captured on film. Gielgud's portrayal, known for its emotional depth and nuanced acting, would have been a must-see. The absence of a filmed version is a significant gap in the film history of one of the greatest actors of the 20th century.

Why Branagh’s Full Text Version?

The full-text version by Kenneth Branagh, released in 1996, is another contender for the title of best Hamlet film. Branagh's adaptation is notable for its faithfulness to the Shakespearean text and the array of talented actors in the cast. It is meritorious to have a complete version of the play, allowing for a deeper understanding of its intricacies and themes.

Why Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead?

I will be cheeky in suggesting that Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, stars Gary Oldman and Tim Roth. While it is a spin-off from the main play, it offers a unique and innovative perspective, focusing on the lesser-known characters and exploring their distinct motivations and fates.

Personal Favourite: The 1980 BBC Production

Speaking from personal experience, my favorite Hamlet adaptation is the 1980 BBC production, starring Derek Jacobi as Hamlet. The minimalist sets and impeccable performances, especially from Jacobi and Patrick Stewart in the role of Claudius, create a stage-like atmosphere that feels authentic and intimate. The scenes between Jacobi and Patrick Stewart, as well as those between Jacobi and Clair Bloom as Gertrude, are particularly masterful in capturing the essence of Shakespearean theater.

Other Notable Adaptations

Several other adaptations stand out for their unique takes on Hamlet. Tom Stoppard's comedic take on the play in his original one-act play "Dog'sberry" is a highlighted version, whereas the RSC's 2009 filmed stage version with David Tennant, Patrick Stewart, and Mariah Gale, directed by Gregory Doran, provides a modern and accessible rendition. Additionally, the NTLive filmed stage version with Benedict Cumberbatch and Ciaran Hinds, directed by Lindsey Turner, offers a fresh interpretation, making for a compelling watch.

Ultimately, the best Hamlet film is a matter of personal opinion, and each adaptation brings something unique to the table. Whether it's the fidelity to the text, the innovative approach, or the compelling performances, these films offer a rich tapestry of Shakespearean storytelling.