The Best Doctor Who Episode Writers: A Debate
The Best Doctor Who Episode Writers: A Debate
When it comes to identifying the best writers of Doctor Who, opinions often differ. Two prominent names stand out:
Robert Holmes: The Prodigal Writer
Robert Holmes undeniably ranks among the best writers in the long and rich history of the classic series. One key reason for his esteemed status is his prolific output and the quality of his scripts. Holmes' writing is marked by its sharp wit and precise storytelling, leaving a lasting impact on the series. This is particularly evident in his work during the seventies.
His contributions to the series go beyond just writing stories. Holmes played a significant role in introducing several iconic elements. He was instrumental in creating the Autons and coined the concept of the Doctor's home planet, Gallifrey. Furthermore, he brought one of the most memorable and beloved stories to the series: "The Time Warrior." This episode, in particular, introduced the Sontarans and the iconic Sarah Jane Smith, a companion who has left an indelible mark on fan culture.
RTD: The People's Poet of Sci-Fi
RTD (Ronald D. Moore), on the other hand, commands a unique place in the hearts of fans. Known by his initials, RTD wrote extensively during the revival of the series in the mid-2000s. His characterizations are often lauded for their depth and complexity, which truly set a precedent for storytelling in Doctor Who.
However, RTD's approach to writing differs from that of many of his contemporaries. He has faced criticism for certain aspects of his writing, most notably for turning the show into a soap opera during his first tenure as script editor. While some fans argue that this made the series less watchable, it cannot be denied that RTD's strength lies in his intimate understanding of the characters and the story. He understands people in a way that allows him to craft nuanced and engaging narratives.
RTD's re-imagining of the series after a 19-year hiatus showed the positive impact of his vision. After his return, the show regained its previous charm and captivating quality, much like the days when he first introduced it. This demonstrates his ability to bring the series back to its roots and deliver a show that fans can enjoy.
A Comparative Overview
The debate around who the best writer is can be likened to a tug-of-war between two powerful forces:
Sharp and Witty: Robert Holmes stands for his quick wit and sharp scriptwriting. His episodes are memorable for their clever one-liners and intricate plots. Complex and Character-Drenched: RTD's approach is more about character development and understanding. His scripts are more emotionally driven and deeply human.Both styles of writing have their proponents and detractors, and both share the common thread of being beloved by fans. The choice between the two often comes down to personal preference, with some preferring the sharp wit and clear narrative of Holmes, while others gravitate towards the complex character studies and emotive storytelling of RTD.
Conclusion
While opinions on who the best Doctor Who episode writer is vary, both Robert Holmes and RTD have left an indelible mark on the series. Whether it's through the clever wordplay and intricate plots of Holmes or the deep character development and emotional resonance of RTD, both writers contribute to the rich tapestry of Doctor Who. The debate will continue, but both have undoubtedly helped shape the show into the beloved classic it is today.