The Acceptability of Referring Males as 'Manly Men': Understanding the Concepts of Tomboys and Masculinity

For years, the term 'tomboy' has been used to describe a girl who exhibits behavior, preferences, and interests that are traditionally associated with boys. However, when discussing males with similar traits, the term often fails to accurately describe them. This raises the question: is it acceptable to refer to males as 'manly men', and what underlies these gender-specific terms? Let's delve into the nuances behind 'tomboy' and explore the concept of 'manly men'.

Understanding Tomboyism

A tomboy is defined as a girl who often acts, dresses, or prefers things typically associated with boys. These characteristics can range widely - from enjoying noisy, physical activities to preferring truck rides over doll play. A tomboy may have an interest in building models, playing outside, or engaging in traditional masculine hobbies like hunting or fishing. She might also dress more casually, favoring jeans and boots over traditional feminine attire like dresses and heels.

The term 'tomboy' is significant because it highlights how societal expectations and gender roles influence children's behaviors and interests. It's important to note that a tomboy is still fundamentally a girl; she may not wish to transition into being a boy. Instead, being a tomboy reflects a more relaxed approach to gender norms, where she is less concerned about maintaining a clean, tidy appearance and more focused on enjoying activities that bring her joy.

Concept of 'Manly Men'

When considering males with similar characteristics, the term 'manly man' comes into play. Unlike 'tomboy', whose primary use is to describe a girl, 'manly man' is used to describe a male individual who exhibits overtly masculine traits. A 'manly man' might be seen as someone who is strongly identified with traditional masculinity, perhaps in a more assertive or dominant way. However, it's crucial to recognize that 'manly man' is not the only term available to describe such individuals. Other terms like 'masculine,' 'covertly masculine,' or 'tough guy' might be more appropriate depending on the context and the specific traits an individual displays.

It's worth noting that both 'tomboy' and 'manly man' serve as descriptors to fit certain gender expectations. However, both terms come with a certain level of criticism and judgment. For example, 'tomboy' can sometimes be used as a way to downplay a girl's femininity, while 'manly man' might reinforce harmful stereotypes about masculinity that contribute to issues like toxic masculinity.

Personal Experiences and Observations

To better understand the concept of a 'manly man,' one might look at personal experiences or observations. Take, for example, the author's younger siblings. The author's sister, while a tomboy herself, had a different approach to play, often engaging in quieter activities indoors with her Barbies. In contrast, the author and their older brother spent time outdoors hunting, fishing, and building forts. Their father raised them with a similar approach that one would with a boy, thus blurring the lines between traditional gender roles.

Both the author and their sister, as well as the author's young daughter, wore clothes that reflected a less formal approach to fashion, often choosing comfortable, rugged attire over more conventional feminine dresses and heels. These personal experiences provide a tangible example of how the term 'manly man' could be used to describe boys or men who exhibit a particular set of masculine behaviors without implying a desire to change their gender identity.

Conclusion

When discussing the terms 'tomboy' and 'manly man,' it's essential to recognize the historical and cultural context in which they are used. Both terms serve to label certain gender behaviors, but they apply differently to boys and girls. While 'tomboy' accurately describes a female who displays traditionally masculine traits, 'manly man' is a descriptor that more appropriately fits males displaying overtly masculine behaviors.

It's important to challenge and deconstruct the societal norms and stereotypes that come with these terms to promote a more inclusive and flexible understanding of gender. By recognizing and appreciating the diverse ways individuals express their gender, we can foster a more accepting and understanding community.

In conclusion, the use of 'manly man' to describe males who exhibit certain masculine traits is entirely acceptable, as it accurately reflects a specific type of masculinity. However, it's crucial to do so with care and sensitivity, recognizing the broader impact and the potential for reinforcing harmful stereotypes.