Television Shows That Underwent Radical Changes During Their Runs

The history of television is replete with shows that have undergone transformative changes throughout their runs. In this article, we will explore some of the most significant retoolings of popular television series, specifically focusing on 'My Three Sons,' 'The Lucy Show,' and 'The Doris Day Show.'

My Three Sons: An Abrupt Yet Complete Reboot

My Three Sons is widely recognized for its abrupt retooling between seasons five and six, a change that would drastically transform the series. Here’s a brief timeline of the modifications implemented:

Network Change: The show moved from ABC to CBS, shifting its broadcast environment. Color Transition: The production transitioned from black-and-white to color, altering the visual experience. Character Changes: Bub, the live-in grandfather, was written out, and he was replaced by live-in Uncle Charley. Additionally, Mike, the oldest son, was also written out, making way for Ernie, the youngest adopted son. This shift significantly altered the dynamics within the family and the overall character development.

These changes led to a substantial transformation in the show's plot and character arcs. Despite these upheavals, Fred MacMurray remained a constant presence, appearing in every single episode across the twelve seasons.

The Lucy Show: A Comedy That Lost Its Form and Direction

The Lucy Show started as a new comedy for Lucille Ball, advocating for a resurgence after her success with I Love Lucy. However, the show's trajectory took a dramatic turn for the worse. The series faced multiple challenges, including:

Network Disruption: The show's original network, Desi Arnaz’s production company, either ceased operations or faced significant changes. Character Replacements: Several main cast members were dropped and replaced, including Gale Gordon, who took over as a radio veteran friend to Ball. Another character was represented by Charles Lane from Citizen Kane, who left because of memory issues and lack of fit with Ball. Writer Exit: Ball was unhappy with her writers from I Love Lucy and they subsequently left the program. Seasonal Changes: Beginning with the fifth season, the show completely changed its premise: Lucy lost her trust fund, moved to California, and found new sources of humor, often derived from guest stars.

By the sixth season, the show had fallen apart, Lucy's character aged poorly, and the physical comedy that defined her became less effective. Despite these challenges, Ball decided to continue, leading to the show’s final season, which was the top-rated but also widely considered the worst.

The Doris Day Show: A Jumbled Saga of Regrets and Reboots

The Doris Day Show is often remembered for its abrupt and multiple reboots. The initial premise saw Doris relocating to a farm in California and trying to raise her two sons. However, the show's subsequent seasons saw dramatic shifts:

Location Changes: The series experimented with relocating Doris to different cities, including San Francisco, reflecting her evolving career and lifestyle. Character Overhauls: The third season saw a complete overhaul, with Doris moving into an apartment above a ristorante, and characters such as her father and children eventually fading into the background. Storyline Redesigns: The fourth season completely revamped the show's direction, making Doris a single, working writer. This transition was so dramatic that viewers could easily lose track of the continuity.

By the final season, the show had become a jumbled mix of elements, with poor pacing and stale humor. This series is a testament to the challenges faced by television shows undergoing such drastic changes during their runs.

Conclusion

These television series exemplify how significant changes can dramatically affect a show's quality and fan base. From My Three Sons to the chaotic reshuffling of characters and storylines in The Lucy Show and The Doris Day Show, each episode represents the evolution and eventual downturn of these cherished programs.