TV Shows and Films That Became More Successful Than Their Originals

When it comes to television and film remakes, some have significantly outperformed their original counterparts. This trend isn’t just confined to the starring actors and directors who bring new life to old stories; it also includes the fan reception, critically acclaimed adaptations, and financial success. Here, we explore some notable examples and delve into the reasons behind their success.

TV Shows

Stargate

Stargate is one of the most successful remakes of an original series. The 1994 TV movie laid the groundwork for the immensely popular TV show that aired from 1997 to 2007. With a budget and special effects well above the original series from the 1970s, the remake generated considerable hype and critical acclaim. The show continues to be appreciated for its detail-oriented plot, developed characters, and expanded universe.

Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica is unequivocally recognized as one of the best remakes of a quality original TV series. The 2004 iteration captured the hearts of fans and critics alike with its superior storytelling, advanced special effects, and thematic depth. While the 1978 version had its moments, the 2004 series built upon the original concept by adding layers of political intrigue, personal struggles, and moral dilemmas, making it a cult classic.

The Office

The US version of The Office aired from 2005 to 2013 and garnered significant praise for its realistic portrayal of office life. The comedic subtleties and character development set it apart from the BAFTA-winning British series it was based on. While both versions were successful, the American adaptation added fresh humor and relatable situations, resonating with a broader audience.

Queer Eye

Another show that transcends its original is Queer Eye. The 2018 reboot not only revived the beloved series from the 1990s but also modernized it to address contemporary issues. The renewed version received critical acclaim and massive popularity, continuing the legacy of the 2003 reboot that itself was an evolution from a 1998 soft reality TV series.

Films

Ocean’s Eleven

The 2001 reimagining of Ocean’s Eleven was a box office success and is widely regarded as the superior adaptation. Directed by Steven Soderbergh, the film starred George Clooney, Brad Pitt, and Matt Damon, among others. It was a blend of wit, action, and comedy that captivated the audience and critics alike, earning critical acclaim and significant financial returns.

Little Shop of Horrors

LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORES (1986) is a cult classic that redefined the original 1960 musical film. The remake, directed by Frank Oz, introduced sharp satire and dark humor, adding a fresh appeal to the classic story of a man-eating plant. This version is considered to have done better than the original, thanks to its innovative visual effects, adaptation to pop culture, and broader audience reach.

Casino Royale

Casino Royale (2006) is often viewed as the definitive adaptation of Ian Fleming’s novel. Directed by Martin Campbell, this film introduced Daniel Craig as the charismatic and gritty James Bond. The reboot reinterpreted the character with modern sensibilities, high-octane action, and accurate historical context, which contributed to its remarkable success and the relaunch of the Bond franchise.

The Departed

The Departed (2006) is a thrilling crime drama that placed the ingenious twist of a Boston cop and a rogue IRA member in the midst of an undercover scheme. Directed by Martin Scorsese, the film starred Matt Damon, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Jack Nicholson. The movie's revolutionary storytelling and intricate plot have cemented its status as a classic, far exceeding the acclaim for its original concept.

The Thing

Remade in 1982 with John Carpenter at the helm, The Thing surpassed the original from 1951 in terms of success. The 1982 version introduced enhanced visuals, atmospheric tension, and psychological depth, making it a landmark film in the horror genre. Its exploration of paranoia and identity further elevated its status as a beloved cult classic.

While Battlestar Galactica is undoubtedly a standout, there are other notable remakes that resonate strongly with audiences. For instance, the mini-series of The Shining (1997) with Steven Weber and Rebecca DeMornay was more faithful to the Stephen King novel than Stanley Kubrick's film, offering a more nuanced portrayal of Jack Torrance’s character. Despite Kubrick’s directorial genius, King’s own take on the subject matter is often considered better for its thematic depth and fidelity to the source material.

Beyond the Originals

Transporting stories from various mediums like books and silent films has also led to numerous successful remakes. For example, the adaptation of The Maltese Falcon from 1941 to 2005, the Wizard of Oz from 1939 to 1980, and Frankenstein from the 1930s and beyond, have all been significant in their own right. However, these adaptations were not strictly remakes but expansions of the original stories, often moving them to different eras or imbuing them with modern sensibilities.

In conclusion, some remakes have proven to be more successful and compelling than their original counterparts. These adaptations often build upon the strengths of the original while bringing new elements that resonate with modern audiences. From elevated storytelling to modern special effects and fresh perspectives, these remakes are not just profitable but also culturally significant.