Subjective Rankings of Star Trek Series: A Comprehensive Discussion

When it comes to ranking the beloved Star Trek series, opinions have always been as varied as they are passionate. This article delves into the subjective views of several fans and evaluates the franchise based on various factors, including plot complexity, acting performances, and overall enjoyment.

Personal Rankings and Preferences

One fan notably lists the Star Trek series in the following order from best to least best: TNG, VOY, DS9, DISC, ENT, PIC, TOS, and TAS. Interestingly, they express particular enthusiasm for new series Section 31, Lower Decks, and SNW (Starship Nile), primarily due to the mystery surrounding Section 31.

This fan's ranking deviates from some traditional views, with notable exceptions being TOS, which they consider foundational and the "George Washington" of the franchise. Even with this high regard for TOS, the fan still finds some of the later series, such as DS9, to be "tedious" and "too heavy and dark."

Varied Preferences and Critiques

The diversity of opinions becomes evident when other fans offer alternative rankings. For example, some fans list DS9 as the top series, followed by TOS and TNG. Others rate ENT higher, appreciating the additional complexity and memorable episodes.

Some fans express frustration with certain series, such as VOY, which they find to be "dreadful for so long." This sentiment highlights the importance of consistent quality throughout a series, which is a factor in the enjoyment of Star Trek.

The Importance of Engagement and Rewatch Value

Engagement and rewatch value are crucial aspects that many fans factor into their rankings. For instance, the fan who favors TNG, VOY, DS9, DISC, ENT, PIC, TOS, and TAS notes that they are rewatching VOY and finding it more consistently good than initially thought. This reflection underscores the evolving nature of a fan's opinion over time.

Another fan mentions ENT as having strong episodes, character arcs, and complexity. This aligns with a broader appreciation for the more intricate storytelling elements that some series offer. However, it's clear that the preference for series like ENT over DS9 stems from different viewing contexts and personal tastes.

The Quest for Perfect Rankings

No matter the ranking, it's important to recognize that these are subjective opinions. One fan humorously poses an intriguing question: "Would you rank The Orville if it were actually a Star Trek show?" This reminds us that the act of ranking can be playful and thought-provoking, but ultimately driven by personal tastes and the unique experiences of each viewer.

Another fan refutes the inclusion of DISC in the fan's ranking, suggesting that it doesn't correspond to any existing Star Trek show. This highlights the ongoing speculation and creative imagination associated with the franchise, where fans often discuss potential storylines and series that haven't yet been realized.

In conclusion, the subjective nature of ranking Star Trek series reflects the rich and varied world of the franchise. Whether you prioritize historical significance, character development, or intricate plotlines, there is something for everyone in the Star Trek universe. As we continue to explore this vast and beloved franchise, our rankings and preferences will undoubtedly evolve, much like the ever-expanding story of the United Federation of Planets itself.