Star Trek: Discovery: Why Fans Disapprove

Star Trek: Discovery is a popular sci-fi series that has garnered both admirers and detractors. The show, which premiered in 2017, has been a source of heated discussions among fans. Some viewers thoroughly appreciate its innovative plot twists and diverse characters, while others find it lacking in the very elements that made previous Star Trek series so beloved.

Why Are Some Fans Unimpressed?

One of the primary reasons some fans are unimpressed with Star Trek: Discovery is their perception of it as a departure from the traditional formula of previous Star Trek series. Critics argue that the show frequently strays from the core essence of what made Star Trek a flagship franchise: engaging narratives that respect and adhere to the established lore and values of the universe.

Weak Plots and Shallow Characters

Many fans, such as myself, have noted that the series often falls short in terms of plot coherence and character development. The reliance on political nuances, while sometimes intriguing, frequently detracts from the fundamental storytelling experience. The political elements, which were initially viewed as an exciting innovation, are now often seen as a significant flaw. The plots frequently lack the depth and complexity that fans have come to expect, and the characters are described as shallow and predictable. For instance, the character of Michael Burnham is often criticized for her lack of depth, as if the writers are forcing her into unrealistic situations solely to meet the demands of plot progression.

Predictability and Slogans

Another criticism is the show's reliance on predictability. The ending of certain seasons, such as Season 2, is often overplayed and predictable, robbing the audience of the thrill of discovery. The show's heavy-handed exploration of modern political topics and initiatives like Stacey Abrams' inclusion seem to lack authenticity and resonance. Critics argue that such political insertions make the series feel like a period piece, destined to become outdated over time. In a future perspective, fans speculate that watching it in 20 years will be akin to looking at a museum exhibit from a bygone era.

Season 2: The High Point

Despite the general dissatisfaction, Season 2 is often cited as the best season of the series. The blend of intriguing plots and character development offers a justified narrative arc. However, the season's ending, with the clear reveal of 'The Red Angel,' does a disservice to the storytelling by making the conclusion overly predictable. This predictability is often pointed out as a major flaw that undermines the tension and excitement of the series.

Conclusion and Future Impact

As Star Trek: Discovery continues to evolve, the series faces a challenging task in maintaining its relevance and engagement with long-time fans. The show has set itself apart with its attempts at innovation, but these innovations sometimes come at the expense of the very storytelling elements cherished by its audience. As we look ahead, the question remains: will Discovery find a way to balance its ambitions with the traditional star trek values, or will it become increasingly obsolete in the annals of the franchise's history?