Stannis and Renly: A Complex Relationship and Their Roles in Westeros

The intricate family dynamics of Westeros play a pivotal role in the A Song of Ice and Fire series. Stannis Baratheon and Renly Baratheon, known as 'the little brothers,' were both influential in the political landscape of Westeros, despite their differing approaches and eventual disputes. In this article, we explore the relationship between Stannis and Renly, focusing on their interactions, their roles in the small council, and their eventual fates.

Introduction to Stannis and Renly

Stannis and Renly Baratheon are the third and fourth sons of King Robert Baratheon, respectively. Due to the complex succession rules of Westeros, neither of them were expected to inherit the Iron Throne. Nevertheless, their experiences and objectives diverged sharply. Stannis, the older brother, was known for his stern demeanor and tactical acumen, while Renly was charismatic and followed a more populist path. Both brothers served on the small council, reflecting their importance in the realm's governance.

Stannis as Master of Ships and Renly as Master of Laws

In A Game of Thrones, Stannis Baratheon took on the role of Master of Ships. This position was crucial, as it involved overseeing the royal fleet, a necessary component of any military campaign. Stannis’s experience in this role allowed him to understand the logistical challenges of war and the importance of sea power in maintaining control over the Seven Kingdoms. His duties encompassed ship-building, maintenance, and the training of sailors, all of which were vital for his brother’s war strategy.

Conversely, Renly Baratheon was named Master of Laws. This title reflects his interest in legal and administrative matters. As Bobonich (2012) points out, Renly was involved in the affairs of the Crown Lands, honing his skills in law and governance. His role in the small council allowed him to shape policies and gain a broader understanding of the realm's legal framework and interpersonal dynamics. Renly’s position as Master of Laws provided him with a unique perspective on the political scene and the potential for civil conflict.

The Family Dynamics and the Political Climate

Stannis and Renly shared a complex relationship, characterized by a blend of rivalry and familial loyalty. Despite their contrasting approaches, both brothers were driven by a desire to secure their position and influence in Westeros. The sibling rivalry was evident in their different methods of governance and their diverging paths to the throne.

Stannis’s choice to confront the Night’s Watch and Nymeria’s demand for justice against Renly are significant moments that underscores the divisions within the family. Stannis, with his tactical and uncompromising nature, found himself at odds with Renly, who believed in a more conciliatory and less rigid approach to governance. The tension between the two was palpable, particularly after Stannis was tricked into forcing the Night’s Watch to choose sides between him and Renly, further exacerbating their enmity.

Conclusion: The Legacy of Stannis and Renly

The complex relationship between Stannis and Renly, characterized by their roles on the small council, played a significant role in the intricate political landscape of Westeros. Despite their differing methods, both brothers were bound by their familial ties and the ambitions that drove them. Their interactions and eventual conflicts reflect the broader themes of honor, loyalty, and political maneuvering that define the A Song of Ice and Fire series.

Through their roles as Master of Ships and Master of Laws, Stannis and Renly each contributed unique insights and experiences to the realm. Their legacies continue to shape the narrative of Westeros, reminding readers of the complexities and uncertainties of power in the Seven Kingdoms.

References:

Bobonich, Christopher. (2012). Plato's Theaetetus: The Argument of the Day. Oxford University Press.