Stannis Baratheon and the Night's Watch: A Feasibility Study

What would it take for Stannis Baratheon to provide the Night's Watch with the men it needs? Let's delve into the feasibility of his proposed solution and explore the challenges he faces.

Recruitment from Enemies and Traitors

Stannis Baratheon's proposal to supply the Night's Watch with recruits from prisoners of war and political enemies is a compelling strategy. In the narrative, he suggests obtaining this manpower from individuals caught in the midst of his war, who would otherwise face execution.

This idea is reminiscent of the historical context in A Song of Ice and Fire where Stannis considers the fate of political enemies and traitors. For instance, in Season 7, Tyrion Lannister attempts to persuade Daenerys Targaryen to allow Lord Randyll Tarly and his son Dickon to take the Black (the title of a member of the Night's Watch). However, this proposition ultimately fails.

Other examples of similar choices include Ser Alliser Thorne, who was given the choice of death or taking the Black. His decision highlights the practicality of this recruitment method.

Challenges in Recruiting During a War

While Stannis's strategy seems straightforward, it faces significant challenges. In the books, the Night's Watch was around 600 men when Jon Snow took command. The War of the Five Kings, though it involves many prisoners, did not significantly benefit the Night's Watch in terms of recruitment.

Key factors include:

Political Shifts: The North became a viable political force, discouraging the use of POWs for recruitment. Logistical Challenges: Recruitment was slowed due to the chaos of war. For example, Yoren, who had around 30 recruits, was stalled by the war in the Riverlands. War Strategies: Most combatants, particularly in the Riverlands, focused on creating chaos and misery rather than engaging in conventional warfare that would result in many POWs.

Given the level of destruction and chaos, Stannis struggles to meet his promise. Instead, he focuses on opening and manning the castles, and resettling the New Gift with wildlings.

Resource Constraints

Stannis's limited forces also pose a significant obstacle. When he arrives at the Wall, he only commands approximately 1,500 men, still engaged in a war. He can provide some men to the Night's Watch, particularly those at the Nightfort, for his own protection, along with those guarding Selyse and Shireen and a few remaining with Melisandre.

His inability to provide more men is a clear demonstration of the constraints of his current situation. His strategy shifts focus to the broader strategic needs of his war efforts, rather than the immediate needs of the Night's Watch.

Thus, while Stannis's vision is commendable, the practicalities of war and the shifting political landscape present significant barriers.