Stannis: The Storm King or a Forgotten Ally in a New Fantasy Battle?

In the tumultuous world of A Song of Ice and Fire, Stannis Baratheon stands as a figure of both grim determination and unwavering loyalism. Let us explore the consequences and strategic implications if Stannis were to declare himself the 'Storm King,' ala Lyonel Baratheon, a lesser-known historical figure in this fictional world.

The Vision of a New Alliance

The audacity of Stannis declaring himself the 'Storm King' would indeed be a masterstroke. This bold move could sow the seeds of a formidable alliance. By aligning himself with Robb Stark, the Northern lords, and the Riverlands, Stannis could counter the vast Lannister armies, including the forces gathered by Tywin Lannister and the Tyrells. This alliance could decisively tilt the balance of power in their favor, potentially snatching victory from the jaws of defeat.

After the War: A Future of Freedom?

Should the war end in victory for the Northerners and their allies, Stannis and Robb might well propose a future where the kingdoms could choose to remain under the rule of the Iron Throne or forge a new path as independent realms, a novel proposal indeed. However, the dynamics of the various kingdoms would vary: Dorne would likely embrace freedom, while the Vale might not be as engaged or concerned. The Reach, on the other hand, would also likely embrace independence.

The Ethical and Legal Quandary

But it is the ethical and legal frameworks of Westeros that render this proposition a non-starter for Stannis. Stannis, deeply ensconced in the principles of law and the belief in a single ruler, the King of the Seven Kingdoms, would never cede the Iron Throne to the Lannisters. In his view, despite the chaos of recent years, Westeros is ruled by the one who sits on the Iron Throne, as was established after Aegon's conquest and continued by the subsequent Baratheons following Robert's Rebellion.

The Blood Sacrifice and His Stand

Stannis' history of naming usurpers—Robb Stark, Joffrey Baratheon, and Balon Greyjoy—speaks volumes about his commitment to the law and the sanctity of the monarchy. His blood sacrifice, during which he whispered these names in the king'sernen, crystallizes the depth of his conviction. These names were more than mere enemies; they were threats to the rightful order. Even in acknowledging Robb Stark as a king, Stannis did so in isolation, marking those who supported him for their loyalty and marking their enemies for treachery.

Ally Against the Undead

With the threat of the dead looming over the realm, Stannis sees no middle ground. Whether Stannis was Stannis or more like Renly Baratheon, his approach to declaring himself 'King' would be rooted in his ironclad principles and the need to solidify his position. If Stannis were not Stannis, but rather a Renly-like figure, he might be compelled to form an alliance with Robb Stark. Both men would stand as partners in rebellion, and their shared philosophical beliefs might forge a powerful front. Additionally, Doran Martell of Dorne could also serve as a valuable ally, given their enmity towards the Lannisters and their desire for independence.

Strategic Importance of the Stormlands

The proximity of the Stormlands to the capital of King's Landing makes them both a boon and a risk. They could launch a decisive campaign against the Lannister stronghold, but they would also be vulnerable to invasion. Forging a coalition of allies, including the Stormlords and northerners, would be essential for Stannis to capitalize on these strategic advantages and ensure a unified front against the undead and the Lannisters.

In conclusion, the idea of Stannis declaring himself the 'Storm King' is a complex one, fraught with ideological and practical challenges. However, it offers both a fascinating narrative opportunity and a powerful strategic alliance. The eternal struggle for the Iron Throne and the survival of the realm may yet see Stannis and Robb united, or for Stannis to forge new paths that ensure the integrity and honor of his role in Westeros.