Should Spider-Man Be an Avenger?

Entangling Spider-Man into the Avengers might seem like a logical step given his immense power and capability. However, the dynamics of these two superheroes suggest that Spider-Man should perhaps take a different path, drawing inspiration from characters like Batman from the DC Animated Universe (DCAU).

The Case for Spider-Man's Independence

The Avengers are designed to tackle massive global and cosmic threats—terrorist organizations, rogue AI, alien invasions, and apocalyptic events. While Spider-Man undoubtedly possesses the skills and strength to contribute in these dire situations, he thrives in a more localized, grounded environment. His role as the 'Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man' is one that he cherishes deeply, focusing on helping daily in his own city rather than venturing into deep-space battles.

Batman's solitary heroism provides a fitting template for Spider-Man. While heroes like Iron Man, Captain America, and the rest of the Avengers are part of a larger organization, Batman navigates his own challenges and cases:

-serving as a lone wolf detective, dealing with mortal threats like theft, murder, and criminal masterminds, broadening his scope to include human-centric issues beyond global crises.

Spider-Man should strike a balance between contributing to the Avengers during major emergencies and maintaining his personal approach. This way, he can remain relevant to the everyday struggles of his neighbors and friends, fostering a connection that is often absent in the more high-powered superhero teams.

Application in the MCU

The current Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) dynamics support Spider-Man's continued journey as an independent hero before fully integrating him into the Avengers' narrative. As of his appearance in The Avengers in Infinity War, Spider-Man faced significant challenges and did not thrive in this environment. Repeated near-death experiences and the separation from his home significantly impacted his psyche and sense of self.

For the upcoming Spider-Man trilogy (likely after Secret Wars finale) and beyond, it makes logistical sense for Peter Parker to maintain a focus on local issues. This approach would serve several purposes:

Highlighting his role as the 'Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man,' Easing into a more prominent Avenger role without overwhelming his civilian persona, Maintaining the relatability of his character to readers and viewers worldwide.

The introduction of Secret Wars can provide a powerful catalyst for Spider-Man's involvement in broader cosmic events while also grounding him in the reality that his identity (and that of his universe) could be at risk. This would underscore his importance as both a hero and a key player in the multiversal saga.

Conclusion

In summary, while Spider-Man's participation in the Avengers is inevitable and necessary for major threats, his continued independence is crucial for his character development and connection with his audience. Balancing these elements will ensure that he remains a beloved and relatable hero, rather than just another member of a larger, more impersonal team. Spider-Man's journey should continue to evolve, providing a rich, intertwined narrative that keeps him a relevant and essential figure in the Marvel Universe.