Speculating the Children of Ser Duncan the Tall: A Theory

George R.R. Martin’s The Song of Ice and Fire series presents a rich tapestry of characters, each with their own intriguing backstories. Among the most intriguing characters is Ser Duncan the Tall, who appears in the first novellas of the series. Many fans have engaged in detailed speculation about Ser Duncan’s lineage, particularly in light of his close relationship with Lady Ashara Dayne. This article aims to explore some of these theories, focusing on potential familial connections, and examining the intricacies of the characters involved.

Potential Children of Ser Duncan the Tall

One of the most notable theories revolves around the possibility that Ser Duncan the Tall fathered a child with Lady Ashara Dayne, a noblewoman he loved. This speculation is partly based on the idea that Duncan’s legacy would continue in some form, especially given the overarching themes of knighthood, honor, and lineage in Martin’s works. Fans have also theorized about the potential connection between Duncan and certain characters in the main series, suggesting that his bloodline could have implications for the larger narrative. However, as of now, these remain speculative with no definitive answers provided in the published works.

Old Nan and Selwyn Tarth’s Father

The theory about the children of Ser Duncan the Tall can be further explored by examining the connections between Old Nan and the Tarth family. According to some narratives, the Tarths are descended from Duncan, and Brienne is his great-granddaughter. We also have evidence suggesting an unknown match between House Targaryen and House Tarth. While these connections are not explicitly stated, they can be pieced together to form a plausible narrative.

One possible scenario is that in 217 AC, Ser Duncan, now known as Egg, returned to Summerhall after the death of Prince Aelor. During this time, Maekar, now the Prince of Dragonstone, likely offered Summerhall to Egg. Daella, Maekar’s daughter, might have gotten married to Jasper Arryn. Meanwhile, Egg may have suggested marrying Rhae off to Donner Stark, a northern lord, which she would have viewed unfavorably. Alternatively, Rhae may have simply preferred Duncan.

Regardless of the circumstances, Rhae was likely unaware that she was pregnant with Duncan’s bastard. She was then married to the Lord of Tarth, an old man with a decimated line. Rhae unknowingly fathered a child with Duncan, who was subsequently passed off as a trueborn Tarth. This child eventually became Selwyn Tarth’s father.

Theories about Old Nan

Another intriguing theory concerns Old Nan. Some fans speculate that Old Nan is Ser Duncan the Tall’s lover. However, such a theory faces several logical challenges:

The implication that Old Nan is 110 years old at the beginning of the main story seems implausible. Logical implications suggest Old Nan had sons who died during Robert’s Rebellion at around 70 years old, which is not a typical human lifespan. Old Nan having several children is less likely given that Ser Duncan is the supposed father of all of them. Old Nan’s presence as a wetnurse for Brandon Stark would be unlikely if she had recently given birth, and her return to Winterfell to serve in this role several years later would be inconsistent with the narrative timeline.

A much more plausible explanation is that Old Nan is Ser Duncan the Tall’s daughter, not his lover. This theory aligns better with the narrative timeline, as it allows for Old Nan to be a child of Duncan who was sent away due to her status as a bastard. Years later, she would return to Winterfell to serve as a wetnurse for Brandon Stark, fitting her later role in the story.

This theory also provides an explanation for the height of Hodor, who is likely the great-great-grandson of Duncan, rather than his great-grandson. This aligns with the fact that Hodor is exceptionally tall, suggesting that his height is inherited through multiple generations.

Conclusion

The theories and speculations regarding the children of Ser Duncan the Tall, particularly his relationship with Lady Ashara Dayne and potential descendants, add depth and intrigue to George R.R. Martin’s world. While these theories remain largely speculative, they offer fascinating insights into the interconnectedness of the characters and the intricate web of family lines woven throughout the series.