Should College and Adult Children Be Spanked if They Break House Rules?

The question of spankings for college and adult children has persisted through various generations. When living under parental roof, adhering to house rules is a given, but what happens when those rules are broken? Many parents consider spankings a traditional form of discipline, while others prefer more modern alternatives. This article explores the issues and considerations surrounding this age-old debate.

Historical Context and Personal Experiences

The concept of spanking for breaking house rules is not new. In times past, such discipline was quite common. For instance, a college roommate in the 1960s recounted a family incident where he was given a spanking from his father after being caught talking back. The consequence was immediate—his buttocks looked reddish and sore, but he took it in stride, saying, “I talked back to him, so I had it coming.” This anecdote illustrates the cultural norms and expectations surrounding parental discipline in the past.

Modern Perspectives and Personal Beliefs

Although the times have changed, some parents still see spankings as an effective tool for disciplining their college and adult children. Even if they no longer live under the same roof, house rules and their associated consequences often remain in effect. A parental home remains a home, and living there still means adhering to household rules. For example, when visiting, a guest who breaks a rule might still face disciplinary action, which can include a spanking.

The Verdict: Parental Responsibility and House Rules

The decision to spank a college or adult child for breaking house rules ultimately rests with the parents. It's a matter of personal preference and what feels right for the family unit. If a parent chooses to implement this form of discipline, they must ensure it is done in a safe and appropriate manner. However, others may advocate for more humane alternatives to physical punishment. The importance lies in the clear understanding and communication of rules and consequences among all household members.

Conclusion: Discipline and Consent

The debate around spanking is not unique to college or adult children. It's a complex issue with various perspectives and cultural norms influencing opinions. While some see consensual spanking as an effective method, especially in specific circumstances, others may not advocate for its use. Ultimately, the key factors are safety, consent, and fairness.

Related Keywords