Introduction

The television series Justified and Longmire share a few surface-level similarities but are fundamentally different in their narrative depth, themes, and characters. Both are set in rural and small-town America, and both are adaptations from literary works that gained popularity before becoming shows. However, beyond these superficial resemblances, the differences are striking. This article delves into the similarities and differences between these two iconic cop shows.

Similarities

Setting in Rural America
Both Justified and Longmire are set in rural and small-town areas of the United States. Longmire takes place in Wyoming, a western state known for its cattle industry, while Justified is played out in Kentucky, a state that leans more towards southern culture and is economically more challenged. This rural backdrop provides a stark contrast to their urban counterparts, setting the stage for a different kind of narrative and character development.

Adaptations from Literary Works
Both series are based on highly successful novels or short stories. Justified was adapted from Harlan Coben's short stories, while Longmire is based on the novels by Craig Johnson. These adaptations bring a rich, well-developed universe to life on screen, with deep characters and complex plots that have captivated audiences.

Differences

Setting Details
The superficial similarities in setting are the only ones these shows share. Detailed differences in the state settings underline the unique qualities of each series. Wyoming, the setting for Longmire, is a state more associated with the West, known for its vast landscapes and cattle ranching. On the other hand, Justified's Kentucky is a more southern state with a different historical and cultural emphasis, and it faces greater economic challenges. These differences are not just geographical but also socio-economic and cultural.

Policing Roles
While both protagonists deal with a significant degree of crime, their roles and methods differ greatly. Walt Longmire, the sheriff of Absaroka County, deals primarily with local crimes, ranging from petty offenses to serious cases. In contrast, Raylan Givens, a federal marshal from Justified, engages in a much broader range of law enforcement activities that include tracking federal fugitives, transporting federal prisoners, serving federal legal processes, and protecting members of the federal judiciary. This disparity in job scope and jurisdiction brings distinct tensions and challenges to their respective narratives.

Character Development
Walt Longmire and Raylan Givens are vastly different characters with contrasting life experiences and personal qualities. Walt has a loving marriage and has successfully raised a well-adjusted daughter. His on-screen persona is one of a natural-born leader, respected by his community and capable of making tough decisions. On the other hand, Raylan Givens struggles with relationships and has a tumultuous personal life. While he eventually becomes a father, his relationship with his daughter, Winona, is complex and not destined for success. Additionally, Raylan often clashes with his superiors, reflecting a less traditional leadership style and highlighting his solitude and individualism.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Justified and Longmire share the broad themes of rural law enforcement and character-driven crime dramas, their specific details, settings, and character development set them apart. Understanding these differences provides a richer appreciation of the depth and complexity of each series. Both shows invite viewers to explore the intricacies of justice and community, offering unique insights into the lives of their protagonists and the small-town America they inhabit.

Related Keywords

Justified vs Longmire, Cop Shows, Western TV Series, Wyoming vs Kentucky