Should an Alien vs Predator Film Reboot Be Retitled to Alien vs Prey?

The debate surrounding the potential retitling of an Alien vs Predator film reboot has sparked considerable discussion. Two titles in particular have been considered: Alien vs Predator and Alien vs Prey. This article explores the merits and drawbacks of both titles, with a focus on their potential market appeal and fit within the existing franchise narratives.

Transforming the Predator Film Franchise

Prey offers a fresh perspective by focusing on the hunted rather than the hunter, a narrative shift that can significantly impact the storytelling dynamics. The title Prey better captures the struggle for survival, highlighting the vulnerability of the protagonists. This shift in focus can add tension and depth to the story, making the narrative more relatable and engaging for the audience.

Why Should It Be Called Alien vs Prey?

From a logical standpoint, if we consider the roles of the Yautja Predators and the Xenomorphs, the latter can be seen as the prey in the traditional Predator film franchise. The intrinsic relationship between these two species is one of hunter and hunted. Therefore, the title Alien vs Prey does not align with the established narrative. Furthermore, it is argued that the title Alien vs Prey is inferior to Alien vs Predator because the latter firmly establishes the conflict between the two most iconic adversaries in science fiction.

Public Opinion and Preferences

Some viewers and fans of the franchise argue that the addition of "Prey" as a title suggests a move towards a more clichéd narrative. Personal preferences in storytelling are subjective, but numerous critics and fans have expressed discontent with newer entries in the Predator franchise. In particular, the 2004 film Alien vs Predator received widespread criticism for its sanitized and underwhelming action sequences, despite its PG-13 rating and the anticipation it generated.

Practical Considerations

The decision to retitle the film should not be made in isolation. The scriptwriters, marketers, and directors must collaborate to ensure that the story delivers a compelling and profitable experience for the audience. The return on investment (ROI) is a critical factor, and it is expected that the title will also influence its market value and success. If the film does not generate significant returns, the financial investment required to produce it would be wasted. In the competitive film industry, every decision must align with the goal of profitability and audience satisfaction.

Renewed Focus on the Original Franchise

Prey has been praised for its fresh and engaging take on the Predator mythology, making it a standout in the franchise. Unlike the 2004 Alien vs Predator, which disappointed audiences and critics due to its lack of action and gore, Prey offers a more authentic and thrilling experience. The 2022 film Prey is set in 1719 in the Northern Great Plains and serves as a prequel to the original Predator films, setting a new standard for the franchise.

Conclusion

The decision to retitle an Alien vs Predator film reboot is a complex one that requires careful consideration. While Alien vs Prey offers a simpler and potentially more marketable title, Alien vs Predator remains the more established and fan-favorite choice. The success of the film will ultimately depend on how well it is executed and marketed, but the importance of aligning the title with the core franchise narrative cannot be overstated. The franchise's strength lies in its iconic characters and the thrill of the hunt, and any deviation from this formula risks alienating its existing fanbase.