Should Your Fictional World Mirror Our World?

The similarity of a fictional world to our own can be a double-edged sword. While it may seem like a weakness, it can actually be a powerful tool for engaging and relatable storytelling. However, this similarity is most effective when used intentionally and with distinct differences. Here’s a deep dive into the nuances of creating a fictional world that mirrors or diverges from our reality.

Is My Fictional World Too Similar to Ours?

Not necessarily. Extremely similar fictional worlds can be beneficial if you have a clear purpose behind it. Contrived or lackluster attempts may come across as a lack of creativity and originality. However, if your goal is to create a parallel universe that closely resembles Earth, this can be effective for readers who want a relatable backdrop for your narrative. This approach is popular in many modern novels, like the Harry Potter series, which draws heavily on familiar elements.

The Importance of Originality

Writers often draw inspiration from their personal experiences, such as locations, situations, or characters. If you’re writing in a genre like romance, mystery, or thriller, you might find it easier to set your story in a place you know. For example, J.K. Rowling used her time in Edinburgh to inspire the world of Hogwarts and its locations. However, if your story falls into genres like fantasy, science fiction, or dystopian, your world may feel more distant and fantastical.

Conscious Differences Are Key

While a similar world can work, it’s often more compelling if you introduce notable differences. For instance, approaching your fictional world with a parallel timeline where notable differences exist—such as the presence of mythical creatures, a unique social hierarchy, or different modes of transportation—can make your narrative more engaging. Such differences not only break the monotony of a too-similar world but also give your story a unique flavor, encouraging readers to embrace the new and compelling aspects you introduce.

Realism vs. Fantasism

When setting your fictional world in general fiction, it should closely resemble the real world. This includes choosing recognizable locations such as big Western cities, African deserts, or European countryside. You can create specific rivers and towns where they don’t exist, but you cannot invent entire mountains or continents as they exist in our world. By doing so, you maintain the believability of your world, which is crucial in engaging readers.

One strategy is to set your story in an unnamed urban center. You can describe the city with such vagueness that readers can’t pinpoint a specific location, thus creating a sense of universality. Similarly, using vague descriptions for geological features can also be effective. For instance, you can mention mountains without specifying their exact ranges, adding a touch of mystery without alienating your audience.

It’s also important to maintain a consistent climate and natural laws in your world, avoiding the mixture of climates from vastly different locations. This level of consistency helps readers immerse themselves in your narrative and nurtures a sense of realism within your fiction.

Conclusion: Balancing Realism and Fantasy

The key is finding the right balance between a relatable, recognizable world and a unique, imaginative one. Whether you create a world too similar to ours or intentionally introduce notable differences, your goal should always be to captivate your readers. By understanding the nuances of your storytelling, you can create a fictional world that resonates with your audience and sets your narrative apart from the rest.