Should 'Supernatural' Continue or End?

Thank you, Vinny, for the A2A. After 15 seasons, the show is finally coming to an end, which, to be honest, seems like a fitting conclusion. The never-ending resurrections of Sam and Dean have worn on viewers’ willingness to suspend disbelief. However, a more promising direction would have been a spin-off series focusing on a less experienced group of hunters tackling a variety of lesser monsters and demons.

The CW and 'Supernatural'

It appears the CW is following this more traditional route. They have cancelled plans for a potential spin-off series, Wayward Sisters, which had a backdoor pilot last year. Meanwhile, other ventures like Supernatural: Bloodlines and a western series about Samuel Colt have opted for reboots of Charmed and Roswell.

The 14th season stats reveal that, while Supernatural is still one of The CW's highest-rated shows, its ratings have been on a downward trend. The 18-49 demographic saw a 0.42 average rating, down by 23% compared to the previous season, which in turn had 1.46 million viewers, down 13% from the 13th season.

Writing and Ratings: A Show’s Lifeline

It's important to note that writing and ratings are crucial metrics for a show's longevity. While the 2018-19 season showed a decline, the show's consistent presence in the top ratings still makes it a viable candidate for continued run. However, as Kripke has openly stated, the show's initial vision was for it to run for only five seasons. In an interview, he clarified, "I’m looking at this season as the [last] chapter in this particular story." This indicates a deliberate end, rather than a forced one due to low ratings.

Why End 'Supernatural'?

Ending a long-running show like Supernatural can be a bittersweet moment for fans. While many will undoubtedly miss the series, the show has outlived its initial 5-season forecast. As Kripke himself put it, 'Supernatural' can close a chapter on its extensive mythology and begin a new one. This approach is proven in shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and The X-Files, which successfully transitioned from one era to another.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, the decision to end 'Supernatural' is not unfounded. The show has had its heyday, and it's now time for a new chapter. Even as fans grieve the end of the original series, a fresh beginning can bring excitement and a new set of characters to captivate viewers. As for Doctor Who, it has shown us that certain series are eternal, but for Supernatural, a poignant conclusion on its own terms could be the most fitting tribute the show's dedicated fanbase could ask for.

Thanks for the A2A, you've given me the opportunity to share my thoughts on this matter.