Should Dramatic Theme Music in UK TV News Be a Thing of the Past?

The use of dramatic theme music in UK TV news has long been a subject of discussion. Some argue that these flourishes are unnecessary and detract from the gravitas of the news. Others believe that such music adds to the overall production quality and professionalism of the broadcast. This article explores the merits and drawbacks of dramatic theme music in UK TV news, discussing whether it should be a thing of the past.

Perceptions and Criticisms

Many viewers find the dramatic music in UK TV news to be detrimental to their ability to focus on the content. For instance, a viewer expressed, "It sounds awful, i just tune out. It sounds like they're about to give out some satire or the results of Strictly Come Dancing." This reaction is not uncommon as the over-the-top music can disrupt the viewer's concentration and credibility of the news being presented.

History and Tradition

On the other hand, there is a rich history and tradition associated with dramatic theme music in UK TV news. Programs like ITN's “News at Ten” and the former BBC Radio 4 (now BBC Radio 4) utilized the sound of Big Ben and Westminster chimes for their broadcasts at 10 PM and 6 PM respectively. These sounds, which many now consider a hallmark of British news, were quite dramatic enough to set the stage for the important information to follow.

The Role of Broadcast Standards and Professionalism

The question arises as to whether dramatic theme music significantly contributes to broadcast standards and professionalism in UK news. Many would argue that while music can enhance the production value, it is ultimately the content that matters most. If a news program is not solely reliant on its music for its impact, it can maintain high standards of professionalism and respect for its audience.

Reevaluation and Potential Change

Given the mixed reactions, it may be time for UK news broadcasters to consider reevaluating their use of dramatic theme music. A shift towards a more straightforward and professional approach could potentially improve viewership and trust. News organizations like the BBC and ITV might consider stripping back unnecessary frills to allow the information to take center stage.

What BBC and ITV Are Doing

Both the BBC and ITV have shown indications of a willingness to change their approach to news broadcasts. For instance, the BBC's decision to omit the Westminster chimes from their news broadcasts has received mixed reactions but signals a trend towards more modern and streamlined content. ITV has also made efforts to update its news format to keep up with changing viewer expectations.

Future Predictions and Call to Action

The future of dramatic theme music in UK TV news is not yet decided. News organizations need to strike a balance between their broadcast standards and the evolving needs of their audience. It is crucial for them to engage with viewers, gather feedback, and make informed decisions about the best way to present the news.

So, might there come a day when UK news on TV no longer features dramatic theme music? Only time will tell. What is certain is that the debate will continue, and viewers will have a say in what they watch.