Shaft vs Superfly: Which Movie Had the Better Song

When comparing the songs from Shaft (1971) and Superfly (1972), both films feature iconic tracks that have left a lasting impact on music and pop culture. This article delves into the musical merits and cultural significance of these songs, providing an in-depth analysis of each.

Shaft: The Theme Song

The theme song from Shaft is masterfully composed by Isaac Hayes. His performance is iconic and has a significant cultural footprint. Hayes is known for infusing the track with a powerful, funky rhythm that perfectly complements the gritty, urban-style plot of the film. This song is more than just a theme; it's a character in its own right, evoking a sense of danger and allure.

Superfly: The Soundtrack

The soundtrack for Superfly was created by Curtis Mayfield, who also performed the title track. Mayfield’s contribution is celebrated for its artistry and social commentary. He weaved a poignant narrative into the lyrics, addressing themes of racism, poverty, and the challenges faced by urban communities. Mayfield is recognized as a soulful and melodic genius, and his title track is a testament to his skill.

Conclusion: A Matter of Preference

Determining which song is superior ultimately comes down to personal preference. If you lean towards a funkier, more upbeat vibe, Shaft may appeal to you more. Isaac Hayes’ track is known for its catchy rhythms and pulsating bassline, which create an energetic and irresistible feel. If you appreciate soulful lyrics and melodies, Superfly is the better choice. Curtis Mayfield’s title track is celebrated for its rich orchestration and socially conscious lyrics, offering a more detailed and emotionally resonant listening experience.

A Critique of the Musical Formula

Both Shaft and Superfly songs share a common limitation in their musical arrangement, which relies heavily on repetitive basslines and a kick drum/ride cymbal combination to create a sense of forward motion. However, Superfly manages to stand out with its rhythmic vitality and more freely mobile bassline, even if it is an ostinato. This gives the song a level of complexity and depth that is not quite matched by Shaft. Though Shaft begins with a melodic kernel, it remains underdeveloped and merely repeated, creating a simplistic and repetitive composition.

Personal Opinion

If forced to choose, some may argue that Shaft is the clear winner as a sex machine, offering a more magnetic and alluring sound to its female audience. Additionally, Isaac Hayes' visuals in the film are more striking than those of any other performer in the film industry. However, a closer look at the cultural impact of both tracks leaves Curtis Mayfield as the standout artist. Mayfield's influence on music and his ability to capture the essence of urban life with lyrical depth and melodic excellence make his song a standing choice for those looking for a more meaningful listening experience.