Was Scarlett O'Hara a Good or Bad Character?

Scarlett O'Hara, the enigmatic and controversial protagonist of Gone with the Wind, is a character that evokes a variety of opinions. While some viewers find her charismatic and formidable, others see her as heartless and manipulative. This article delves into her complexities and examines whether Scarlett is more of a good or bad character, based on various perspectives.

Initial Perception

Initially, the character of Scarlett O'Hara captivated me with her charm and wit, as she seemed to entice the attention of multiple gentlemen. There was a certain charm in her sly demeanor that made her endearing, albeit peculiar. However, as the narrative of the film unfolds, her flaws become more apparent, and she starts to appear more annoying and less fit as the main protagonist.

Protagonist or Antagonist?

Depicting Scarlett as a multi-faceted character, rather than a well-rounded, perfect protagonist, reflects her realism. Her actions and traits are not always compassionate or selfless, which makes her more human and relatable. For instance, when she marries Frank Kennedy to reclaim money his betrothal to her sister deemed necessary, it showcases her stubborn and disrespectful nature towards Melanie and other likable characters.

Despite her negative attributes, the story emphasizes her determination and survival skills amidst the tumultuous circumstances of the Civil War. Her ability to navigate life's challenges, regardless of the obstacles, makes her a compelling and strong protagonist, which some viewers find impressive and admirable.

Real Life Implications

When considering Scarlett O'Hara's behavior in the context of the 21st century, her actions seem more absurd and unsettling. Questions arise about her suitability as a role model, given her manipulative and selfish nature. In modern terms, she would likely be diagnosed with narcissistic personality traits, which are destructive to personal and familial relationships.

The film portrays a character deeply rooted in her Southern heritage and struggles, making her actions grounded in her historical context. Scholars often debate her character, highlighting how, through her flaws and strengths, she exemplifies the complexities of the human condition. This multi-dimensional portrayal, rather than diminishing her appeal, actually contributes to her enduring fascination with audiences.

Summary of Traits

Scarlett O'Hara possesses a plethora of contradictory traits: high-spirited, spoiled, stubborn, selfish, determined, brave, narcissistic, vain, self-centered, sarcastic, jealous, petty, coquettish, and unladylike. These diverse qualities contribute to her complexity as a character and offer insightful commentary on the human experience.

Ultimately, the character of Scarlett O'Hara represents a blend of attributes that reflect both the good and the bad aspects of human nature. Whether she is viewed as a resilient survivor or a manipulative antagonist largely depends on the perspective from which one views her actions and motivations.