Sauron's Ringwraiths: Could They Have Defeated Númenor’s Ar-Pharazn instead of Surrendering?

The hypothetical scenario of Sauron having the Ringwraiths Nazg?l during the time of Ar-Pharaz?n presents an intriguing discussion on power dynamics in Middle-earth. This essay explores the potential impact of the Ringwraiths on the final confrontation with Númenor and the strategic decision of Sauron to surrender.

Context

Sauron and the Ringwraiths: The Nazg?l were powerful servants of Sauron, created from men who were corrupted by the Rings of Power. They were formidable in battle, instilling fear and chaos among their enemies.

Ar-Pharaz?n: He was the last King of Númenor, known for his immense strength, military prowess, and the might of the Númenórean army. Considered one of the most powerful forces in Middle-earth, the Númenóreans were noted for their superior naval and military capabilities.

Key Factors

Númenórean Might

The Númenóreans possessed superior naval and military capabilities. Ar-Pharaz?n led a massive army to Middle-earth, with numbers, training, and experience that made them a formidable opponent. The sheer scale and power of the Númenórean forces would have posed a significant challenge to any potential conqueror.

Sauron's Strategy

Having withstood previous defeats, Sauron often employed manipulation, fear, and deception. His choice to surrender to Ar-Pharaz?n was strategic, aimed at gaining power from within Númenor rather than confronting its might directly. This was part of his long-term plan to corrupt Númenor from within, ensuring a more favorable environment for his return.

The Nazg?l's Role

Boasted as formidable in combat and capable of instilling terror, the Ringwraiths could have provided Sauron with significant advantages. Their presence would have raised the stakes and potentially altered the dynamics of the confrontation. However, their overall effectiveness depended on the strategy employed and the ability to instill fear in the Númenórean forces. Cultivating fear and spreading chaos could have weakened the resolve of the Númenórean army, but it would not have guaranteed victory over a strong adversary.

Conclusion

While the presence of the Ringwraiths would have certainly raised the stakes and potentially altered the dynamics of the confrontation, it is highly unlikely that Sauron could have outright defeated Ar-Pharaz?n and the Númenórean army. The strength and military prowess of Númenor, coupled with Ar-Pharaz?n's formidable leadership, would have posed a considerable challenge.

Ultimately, Sauron's choice to surrender was influenced by a combination of factors, including his understanding of Númenórean strength, his desire to manipulate events to his advantage, and the long-term goal of corrupting Númenor. While the Ringwraiths could have made a significant difference, it is improbable that they alone would have turned the tide in Sauron's favor against such a powerful adversary.

The hypothetical scenario underscores the complexity of power dynamics in Middle-earth and the strategic decisions that shape the outcome of conflicts. While Sauron's Ringwraiths could have impacted the battle, Ar-Pharaz?n's military might and strategic acumen ensured that any victory remained elusive.