The Rise of Denethor II

The role of the Steward of Gondor was a critical one during a tumultuous period in Middle-earth's history. Notably, Denethor II, the son of Ecthelion II, ascended to this position amidst numerous threats and challenges. Understanding his journey and eventual rise to power is essential to understanding the legacy of Gondor in the Second and Third Ages.

Stewardship Lineage

Denethor II came from a lineage of stewards who had taken charge of the kingdom after the kingship ended. His father, Ecthelion II, served as the Steward during a time when Gondor faced increasing threats from Sauron and his forces. Ecthelion's descendants continued this tradition, maintaining the kingdom in the king's stead when the line of kings was cut short by the disappearance of the last king, Ernur, in a challenge to the Witch-king of Angmar.

The Last King and the Rise of Denethor

The disappearance of Ernur in 3019 of the Third Age marked the definitive end of the line of kings in Gondor. This was followed by the stewardship of Ecthelion II, who ruled until 2477, when he perished during the Siege of Gondor. Denethor II, the rightful successor, ascended to the position of Steward under these trying circumstances.

The Palantír and Denethor's Rise

Denethor II's possession of the Palantír of Minas Tirith played a significant role in his rise to power. As a seeing stone, it allowed him to communicate and gain insights across Middle-earth, potentially revealing strategies that could bolster Gondor's defenses. However, Sauron also exploited the Palantír, leading Denethor to experience moments of paranoia and despair. This manipulation further fueled his isolation and disconnection from the true leaders and allies of Gondor, such as Aragorn.

Challenges and Rise to Royalty

Despite the challenges, Denethor II demonstrated his capabilities as a leader. His intelligence and military prowess were well-known, and he used these attributes to maintain Gondor's stability. However, his rule was marked by a significant turning point triggered by the War of the Ring. As Sauron was defeated and the true heir of Isildur, Aragorn, emerged, Denethor's claims to the throne were questioned. Aragorn played a crucial role in legitimizing his lineage:

A Proven Lineage

Healing Hands: One of the key proofs of Aragorn's legitimacy was the renown of his ancestor being skilled healers. Aragorn and his house were well-known for their medical prowess, which was a significant badge of honor in Gondor. Command of the Dead: Aragorn's ability to command the army of the dead was a unique and powerful trait, reserved only for the heir of Isildur. This demonstrated his bloodline and the promise of a return to Gondor's former glory. Use of Royal Symbols: Aragorn also used the banners and sigil of the King, the tree and stars, to strengthen his claim. These symbols were integral to the royal identity and underscored his right to the throne.

Through these primary ways, Aragorn was able to prove his lineage and claim his rightful place on the throne, marking a significant shift from the stewardship of Denethor II to a more traditional rule by a king.

Decline and Tragic End

Despite his initial success, Denethor II's rule was ultimately marked by tragedy. His relationship with his sons, Faramir and Boromir, contributed to his despair and isolation. The loss of Boromir in the service of the Fellowship and the perceived failures of Faramir further deepened his paranoia and despair. These emotions led Denethor to a tragic end, culminating in his madness and the destruction of himself and his house.

The rise and fall of Denethor II serve as a significant narrative in the history of Gondor, highlighting the complex dynamics between rulership, leadership, and the enduring threats faced by Middle-earth.