Revisiting the Timeline of ASOIAF: The Impact of Altering Cersei's Children

In the intricate world of A Song of Ice and Fire, one significant alteration could have a profound impact on the entire narrative: changing the number and birth order of Cersei Lannister's children. Maddieknighty, a dedicated fan and fanfiction author, proposes reworking Cersei's progeny to four children instead of three. This article explores the implications of this change and how it would shift the dynamics of the series.

Key Changes in the Timeline

According to Maddieknighty, the primary alteration involves changing the birth order and dates of Cersei's children:

Rosamund (born in 288) Tommen (born in 291) Myrcella (born in 284) Joffrey (born in 286)

This change would have significant implications, particularly regarding the ages of Rosamund and Myrcella. Maddieknighty suggests that this alteration could greatly impact Cersei's relationships and the overall story progression.

Impact on Myrcella's Age and Marriage

One of the most noticeable impacts would be the age at which Myrcella is introduced into the narrative. At 14, this means she would be younger during the events of A Feast for Crows. Maddieknighty notes that this could imply a different timeline for Myrcella's wedding to Robb Stark, as it removes the previously assumed five-year gap.

With Myrcella already married to Robb at the start of the series, the dynamics of the story change dramatically:

Robb and Myrcella's relationship complicates the plot further Whether Myrcella and Robb's story was historically meant to be developed differently under Martin's original outline The significance of Myrcella's role in the Council of War and her subsequent struggles in the North

Investment and Dynamics

Maddieknighty also suggests that this change would create a stronger investment between the Starks and Lannisters. For instance, during the incest discovery scene, Ned Stark's stake in the families would increase dramatically. His dilemma would shift from just Cersei and her children to the safety and future of his own family, further complicating the narrative.

Character Arch Development

Several characters' arcs could be significantly impacted:

Jaime Lannister: He could develop a character arc beyond A Dance With Dragons, with a redemption story that involves protecting Myrcella's children. Loras Tyrell: His meeting with Robb Stark after the Red Wedding could take on a less confrontational tone, showcasing their bond. Petyr Baelish: His plans to secure the Lannister-Phelan alliance through Melantha could be further detailed, adding depth to Littlefinger's schemes.

Clarifying Plot Points

The change would also clarify several plot points:

The Dornish Plot: A clearer storyline for Rosamund and her role as an heir could align better with GRRM's original vision. Factions in Winterfell: The identity crisis and personal struggles of Robb Stark could be further explored, adding emotional depth to his character arc. Littlefinger's Plans: The Littlefinger-Phelan alliance could be better understood, providing a clearer motive for Ned Stark's position as Hand of the King.

Conclusion

Overall, Maddieknighty's proposal for altering Cersei's children timeline presents a compelling case for revisiting the intricate dynamics of A Song of Ice and Fire. This change would offer a richer, more nuanced storytelling experience, potentially unlocking unimagined plot points and character developments. While some aspects of the world as originally envisioned by GRRM may remain unchanged, the ripple effects of this alteration could be profound.