Renly vs. Stannis: Why Renly Baratheon Commands More Support and a Larger Army in Game of Thrones

Renly Baratheon, the charismatic younger brother of King Stannis Baratheon, garners more support and commands a larger army during the events of the TV show Game of Thrones. This article delves into the key factors behind Renly's appeal and military strength compared to his stern and unforgiving sibling.

Charismatic Leadership

Renly is portrayed as a charming and likable character, which significantly enhances his ability to attract followers. His personality stands in stark contrast to Stannis, who is often portrayed as stern and inflexible. Renly's charisma makes him appealing to both commoners and nobles alike, ensuring a broader base of support.

Political Alliances

Renly effectively builds alliances with powerful houses, particularly through his marriage to Margaery Tyrell. The Tyrells, one of the wealthiest and most influential families in the realm, secure Renly's access to their extensive resources and troops. This strategic alliance significantly enhances Renly's power and influence.

Public Perception

Renly's public image plays a crucial role in his appeal. He positions himself as a more legitimate and attractive claimant to the throne, benefiting from his youth and vitality in contrast to Stannis's grim demeanor. Many lords and commoners view Renly as a king who can bring stability and prosperity, especially after the chaos of the War of the Five Kings.

Military Might

Renly quickly assembles a large and well-equipped army, drawing on the support of the Tyrells and their vassals. His camp is depicted as well-organized, showcasing his ability to mobilize forces effectively. Additionally, Renly's position as the Lord Paramount of the Stormlands and the potential loyalty of Stormland's fighting troops further bolster his military strength.

Stannis' Reputation

Stannis, while capable and determined, often alienates potential supporters with his rigid adherence to law and order and his association with Melisandre's controversial practices. His reputation as a harsh and uncompromising ruler deters many from aligning with him.

Conclusion

In summary, Renly's charisma, strategic alliances, favorable public image, and ability to raise a strong military force contribute to his greater support and larger army compared to Stannis. Stannis's rigid nature and reputation hinder his ability to rally allies, ultimately placing Renly as the more formidable opponent.

The show and the book diverge in some aspects, but at the core, Renly's easier influence and perceived stability ensure that he commands a larger initial host than Stannis. Despite Stannis's military acumen, Renly's charismatic personality and strategic alliances give him an undeniable advantage. This difference in character and approach highlights the importance of political and military strategy in the complex world of Westeros.