Reflections on New Doctors in Doctor Who: A Personal Journey

I am 64 years old, and my affection for Doctor Who started to wane after watching Tom Baker. The reboot didn't quite resonate with me, and my fondness for the show is more a matter of personal taste. From the grainy old black and white episodes with the grouchy first doctor to the enigmatic Susan Foreman, the rich tapestry of characters and storylines has been a source of wonder and imagination for me. The quirky humor of Tom Baker, with his alien constable who never draws a gun, instilled a deep sense of morality in me.

While my interest may have shifted, I am compelled to share my thoughts on the latest Doctors, particularly Jodie Whittaker, and the era she represents in the show's long history.

Tom Baker: A Golden Era

There was something captivating about Tom Baker's era. His Doctor was a figure of mystery, a creature of twinkling eyes and a sardonic sense of humor. The storyline "Revenge of the Cybermen" and the episode “The Making of a President” showcase the versatility and charm of his performance.

The New Doctors: A double Edged Sword

It's essential to consider the actors beyond the character they portray. In my opinion, playing the version of the Doctor can be a double-edged sword. Great actors, such as Matt Smith, have entirely different material to work with, and their portrayal often becomes entangled with the exploration of the companion roles. This might overshadow their ability to bring their unique energy to the role.

Jo Martin: A Surprising Success

However, one cannot deny the impact and success of Jo Martin, who portrayed an alternative version of the Doctor. Her fluid transition from the companion 'Ruth' to the alternative Doctor demonstrated her adaptability. Jo's Doctor was authoritative, complex, and occasionally ruthless. Her portrayal was a relief for many fans, establishing a new standard for female Doctors.

Jodie Whittaker: A New Chapter

Jodie Whittaker, the 13th Doctor, marks a significant milestone in the show's history. She is not the best Doctor Who or the best female Doctor Who, but her portrayal has its merits. Her energy and enthusiasm are refreshing. While her costume might be seen as a bit too casual, it does reflect the show's modern sensibilities. It's important to note that this is subjective and personal, much like my fondness for the grainy, black and white episodes of old.

The Show: A Work in Progress

The current Doctor Who has shown improvements over past seasons. Episodes like "Rosa," "Demons of the Punjab," and "The Witchfinders" have been strong, with a quasi-historical feel that resonates well with the show's roots. However, the pacing of stories can be off, and some episodes could benefit from a more layered narrative. It would be ideal to have more two-part episodes to fully explore the stories and themes.

More Engagement for Companions

One area that requires improvement is the dynamic between the companions and the Doctor. Episodes like "Resolution" show potential, but more individual character development would enrich the narrative. The idea of the First Doctor's "The Keys of Marinus" could be a reference for this, where the companions have their own adventures and come together in the end.

Comparisons with Previous Doctors

While Jodie Whittaker's Doctor is different, there are aspects I enjoyed, such as the environmental episode and the handling of companions. The costume, however, seems understated compared to some of her predecessors. A true historical episode, akin to the Fifth Doctor's "Black Orchid," would add depth and intrigue to the current lineup.

Conclusion

As an(observer, I can say that the current iteration of Doctor Who is worth watching. It has its flaws, but it also has its strengths. The show is continually evolving, and its legacy is one of adaptation and innovation. Whether you are a long-time fan or just delving into the series, there is always something new and compelling to discover.