Reflections of Society: Do Films and TV Shows Foster Narcissism and Immoral Behavior?

Art often serves as a mirror to society, reflecting its complexities without necessarily creating them. For many decades, films and TV shows have been criticized for fostering narcissistic behavior and immoral conduct among viewers. However, is this portrayal a true reflection of the content's actual influence?

The Mirror of Society

It is true that human society has existed for tens of thousands of years before the advent of film and television. These mediums are merely reflections of the societies that create them and are not schools for manners. Art, including films and TV shows, simply highlight and sometimes explore societal issues, rather than causing them.

One of the key criticisms is the portrayal of immoral behavior. However, the concept of morality is subjective, varying from one person to another. What one deems as immoral might be considered acceptable in another context. For example, if a 13-year-old girl and boy simply share a bed without engaging in any physical activity, it could be seen as completely innocent in one culture while viewed as inappropriate in another. Television and film often reflect different cultural norms and perspectives.

Reflections of Childhood and Personal Choice

The argument that films and TV shows are responsible for fostering narcissism and immoral behavior overlooks the essential role of human development. Narcissism, often stemming from childhood abuse, is not something that can be wholly attributed to media exposure. Most children spend their formative years watching cartoons and engaging with media that is generally focused on entertainment and audience engagement rather than character development.

Moreover, moral behaviors are largely developed in the home environment. Families play a critical role in shaping an individual's sense of right and wrong. The influence of religion can also greatly affect a person's moral compass, though this guidance can be both positive and negative. Certain religious beliefs might lead to harmful or repressive behaviors, while others offer supportive and constructive moral guidance.

Television's Role as a Mirror

When discussing the influence of media, it's important to remember that television and films primarily reflect life as it exists in society. A two-hour film or TV show is not a comprehensive guide to life or a causative factor for complex conditions like narcissism. The portrayal of certain behaviors in these mediums is often exaggerated for dramatic or comedic effect and is meant to engage and entertain rather than incite change. People who watch these shows typically retain their own moral compass and do not internalize the negative portrayals.

When individuals watch films or television, they often view these depictions critically. A person who sees problematic behavior on screen is more likely to be critical of it and not aspire to replicate it. The autonomy and critical thinking of the viewer are crucial in determining how they respond to the content they consume. In essence, media consumption is a complex and deeply individual experience.

Conclusion

While films and TV shows can certainly depict a wide range of behaviors and moral dilemmas, it is important to recognize that these are reflections of society and not direct influencers of individual behavior. The impact of media is significantly influenced by personal experiences, upbringing, and individual values. Films and TV shows are tools that reflect the society we live in, and it is up to the individual to interpret and interact with them accordingly.