The Reality of Forensic Evidence in TV Shows

When it comes to forensic accuracy, particularly in shows like CSI, Bones, and NCIS, there's a clear desire to strike a balance between realism and entertainment. These popular television series have become a part of popular culture, but how accurately do they portray the real-world practice of forensic science?

Reality Check

Procedure dramas like CSI, Bones, and NCIS often rely on expert advisors and consultants to ensure that their portrayals of modern forensics are as accurate as possible. However, tighter production timelines and the need to maintain audience engagement necessitate a degree of creative liberties. This often results in a portrayal that is not only faster-paced but also lags behind current forensic practices by 10 to 25 years.

Artistic License and Real-World Forensics

While these shows use a realistic basis, CSI, Bones, and NCIS frequently take artistic liberties that can mislead viewers. One notable example is the belief that identical twins cannot be differentiated using DNA for paternity or crime cases. This is not entirely true, as advancements in forensic technology have made it possible to distinguish identical twins under certain conditions. For instance, if one twin is the victim, forensic investigators can perform additional tests to identify them accurately.

According to Bones writer and consultant Erik Bergner, DNA degradation is a significant hurdle. Identical twins can still be distinguished if the DNA sample is fresh and of high quality. However, if the sample degrades to a certain point, it becomes difficult to distinguish the twins. As of around 2005, this was a more significant challenge, but advancements have improved the ability to differentiate between twins.

College Courses and Real-World Forensics

Interested in learning about real forensic science? Taking college courses is the best way to get an accurate understanding of the field. Many universities offer courses in forensic science that cover the latest techniques and technologies. These courses are taught by experts in the field and provide a comprehensive understanding of the methods used by forensic investigators.

Conclusion

While TV shows like CSI, Bones, and NCIS strive for realism, they often take artistic liberties that can mislead viewers. It's important for viewers to understand the gap between the entertainment portrayed on TV and the real-world practices of forensic science. If you're interested in pursuing a career in forensic science, enrolling in college courses is the best way to get an accurate and up-to-date education.

Ultimately, the balance between reality and entertainment is crucial. While these shows can inspire fascination with forensic science, they should not be taken as an accurate reflection of real-world practices. For a detailed and expertly informed understanding, consulting educational resources is recommended.