Ranking the Batman Movies: A Comprehensive Analysis

When it comes to ranking the Batman movies, several aspects come into play:

Introduction

The Batman franchise has captivated audiences for decades with its rich mythology and complex characters. Join me as we delve into the ranking of the Batman film series, prioritizing the Batman aspect over the movie aspect. We'll explore the story, directing, cinematography, effects, acting, atmosphere, and score to determine the best Batman installment.

Story (S)

The story is crucial in any superhero film. It sets the tone and direction for the viewer's experience. Among all the Batman films, Batman Returns (1992) stands out with its storytelling that pays homage to the complexity and essence of the original character.

1. Batman Returns (1992)

Story: 10/10 - This movie is a true representation of the essence of Batman. Despite Kevin Spacey being the worst choice for Batman, the story is masterfully crafted, deserving of its perfect score.

Directing (D)

Directing is about bringing the story to life with a unique vision and style. For the first two Batman films, a master of the Gothic genre, Tim Burton, takes the helm, making Batman (1989) and Batman Returns (1992) essential viewing.

2. Batman (1989)

Directing: 7/10 - While very similar to its successor, Batman (1989) feels more like an initial experiment. The directorial style, however, is crucial in setting the tone for future films. Note that this is Mr. Burton's Batman, which defines the sound of the franchise.

3. Batman Returns (1992)

Directing: 8/10 - Tim Burton's Batman Returns is a pinnacle of the genre, preserving the core essence of Batman with a perfect blend of Gothic elements and a compelling narrative.

Cinematography (C)

Cinematography enhances the visual storytelling, creating a unique cinematic experience. The Batman Forever (1995) film stands out with its vibrant and comic-book-like visuals.

4. Batman Forever (1995)

Cinematography: 9/10 - Despite its flaws, Batman Forever is colorful and visually striking, even when it strays from the realistic aspects of the franchise. Its bold and bizarre color palette is reminiscent of comic books.

Effects (E)

Special effects are a crucial component in modern superhero films. Nolan's trilogy, while groundbreaking, falls flat due to its generic and soulless approach.

5. The Dark Knight (2008)

Effects: 5/10 - Batman (2008) and its subsequent films' effects are generic and soulless. Heath Ledger's Joker, over the top and out of place, adds little to the overall experience. Despite the pacing issues, the minimalistic and somber score by Hans Zimmer fails to elevate the production.

6. Batman Begins (2005)

Effects: 5/10 - Batman Begins (2005) suffers from the same issues as the follow-up and is the most polarizing of Nolan's films. The effects are flat and murky, detracting from the overall quality.

Acting (A)

The acting performance plays a pivotal role in bringing the characters to life. Heath Ledger's portrayal of Joker in Batman (2008) is a standout despite the film's shortcomings.

7. Batman (2008)

Acting: 7/10 - Heath Ledger's performance is exceptional, but the overarching film fails to live up to the promise. The costume and Ledger's vocal inflections add depth to the character, even in a film that is otherwise generic and overblown.

8. Batman Returns (1992)

Acting: 7/10 - Michael Keaton's portrayal of Batman in Batman Returns is a strong performance, despite being perhaps the least ideal choice for the role.

9. Batman Forever (1995)

Acting: 7/10 - Jim Carrey's portrayal of the Joker is perhaps the highlight of the film, despite Carrey being more a Riddler than a Joker. His performance is consistently memorable.

10. Batman Begins (2005)

Acting: 6/10 - Christian Bale's performance is solid, but the character felt more like a Batman clone, lacking the charm and depth of previous installments.

Atmosphere (S)

Atmosphere creates the environment and mood of the film, crucial for a genre that thrives on a specific aesthetic. The Burton films excel at this aspect, especially Batman Returns (1992).

11. Batman Returns (1992)

Atmosphere: 10/10 - Tim Burton's perfect blend of gothic horror and comic book elements creates a dark and atmospheric world for Batman.

12. Batman (1989)

Atmosphere: 8/10 - Burton's Batman sets the tone for what would become the definitive interpretation of the character, though it lacks the later refinement of atmosphere.

Score (A)

Score complements the overall mood and enhances the emotional impact of the film. Danny Elfman's work in Batman Returns (1992) is a standout.

13. Batman Returns (1992)

Score: 10/10 - Danny Elfman's score is a perfect fit for the darker, more mature tone of the film, adding depth and emotional resonance.

14. Batman (1989)

Score: 10/10 - Elfman's score is iconic, defining the soundtrack for the franchise.

Conclusion

Batman Returns (1992) and Batman (1989) stand tall as the best Batman films, while the Burton and Schumacher films are more atmospheric and visually striking. Nolan's trilogy, while critically acclaimed, lacks the depth and atmosphere needed to truly embody the spirit of Batman. Batman and Robin (1997) and The Dark Knight Rises (2012) are the nadir of the franchise, serving as a stark contrast to the earlier eras of the character.

Ultimately, Batman Returns (1992) takes the crown as the best Batman movie, balancing story, directing, effects, atmosphere, and score in perfect harmony to create the definitive interpretation of Batman on the big screen.