Objective or Subjective: Jerry Seinfeld and Bernie Mac - The Funniest Comedian of All Time

Whether Jerry Seinfeld is right in calling Bernie Mac the funniest comedian of all time is subjective and depends on personal taste in comedy. Bernie Mac was known for his unique style, sharp wit, and ability to connect with audiences, particularly through his work on The Bernie Mac Show.

Many fans and comedians consider him one of the greats, often praising his observational humor and charisma. However, comedy is highly personal, and opinions on who is the funniest comedian can vary widely. Other comedians such as Richard Pryor, George Carlin, or Robin Williams also have strong followings and are often cited as among the best.

How People Perceive Comedy

I have a few favorite comedians, each in their own way, who are the funniest to me. Also, it depends on my mood. Bernie Mac was definitely the funniest comedian to Jerry Seinfeld, but that is just his opinion. If I had to pick one person to be my favorite, I would say Robin Williams. He is the first person I noticed making people laugh. I was only 4 years old when I noticed. Robin Williams was a comedic genius, with his incredible abilities to bring joy to his audience.

Personal Perspectives on Comedy

Jerry has a right to his opinion, and I really liked Bernie Mac. But “funny” is greatly subjective, temporal, and so is “all time.” My favorites, in no particular order, include Richard Pryor, George Carlin, Jackie Mason, Dom Irrera, Flip Wilson, Red Fox, Sid Caesar, Jonathan Winters, Bill Baar, Phil Silvers, Lenny Clarke, Don Rickles, Bob Newhart, Shecky Greene, and Dave Chappelle. I’m sure I’m forgetting people.

Measuring Humor

Humor is lauded and criticized for so many different qualities, some more objective than others. How you rate a comedian depends on the weight you give the quality your favorite excels at.

Objective Criteria for Judging Comedians

Originality Cleverness Controversial Tasteful Insightful Crude Physical Brave

Sometimes you find yourself attracted to a comedian, and you don't know why. I don't like physical comedy, but I found Robin Williams so likeable that it amplified his humor. He may be the only comedian who could actually make me laugh out loud.

Examples of Different Types of Humor

The perception of what is funny is extremely personal. How would you measure it! Maybe a better way to put it is Jerry Seinfeld finds Bernie Mac the funniest comedian in his experience. Funny is a heuristic; it means nothing to anyone but the person experiencing it. I suppose there are objective criteria for judging comedians, but I just don't know what they are.

It would be interesting to know how Seinfeld explains or defends his claim. Humor is complicated. But thanks for asking about Bernie Mac and Seinfeld. I had no idea Seinfeld admired him. Now I'm going to have to Google it to find out why.

Ultimately, this debate about who is the funniest comedian is a bit of fun, highlighting the subjective nature of comedy and the diverse array of talents that make people laugh. Whether it's through sharp wit, observational humor, or relatable relapses, each comedian has their own unique way of making their audience smile.

Key Takeaways:

Comedy is highly personal and subjective. Opinions on the funniest comedian can vary. Humor is complex and multifaceted.

Do you have a favorite comedian? Share your thoughts in the comments below!