Do Many Indonesians Dislike Malaysians? Why or Why Not?

Beloved neighbors and brothers in faith, Indonesia and Malaysia share a history intertwined with cultural, linguistic, and historical similarities. The idea that most Indonesians inherently dislike Malaysians is a broad and inaccurate statement. One must consider the nuanced nature of cross-border relations where tensions and disagreements do arise, but these pockets of conflict do not reflect the entirety of the population's attitudes.

Shared Bonds and Cultural Affinity

Around 60% of both populations converted to Islam at roughly the same time, creating a cultural and historical foundation that serves as a unifying force. The two countries share the Malay Archipelago and have many common interests. While instances of friction may take place due to specific political or diplomatic issues, these disputes do not encapsulate the general sentiment of the entire population.

Instances of Tension and Dispute

Tensions can arise from specific events, such as the mistreatment of Indonesian migrant workers by some Malaysians, which is a significant and regrettably ugly truth. This injustice has led to bitterness and anger among many Indonesians. Additionally, there is a perceived dilution or misunderstanding of Indonesian cultural heritage, with Indonesian cultural elements like Wayang Kulit, batik, and traditional songs being claimed as part of Malaysian culture without acknowledgment of their original source.

These issues are not shared sentiments among all Indonesians. I, for one, prefer that my children watch Upin Ipin, a fun and educational cartoon that celebrates friendship without resorting to stereotypes and body shaming. This attitude reflects a more nuanced view of cross-border relations.

Challenges in Cross-Border Relations

Irrespective of the cultural and historical ties, tensions and misunderstandings can still exist. Unfortunately, negative remarks and criticisms about Indonesia often come from a small yet vocal group of Malaysians. On platforms like Quora, I have witnessed harsh critiques directed at Indonesia's moderate and tolerant Islam, which some describe as mere propaganda. It is equally ironic to observe that Islam in Malaysia can be rigid and discriminatory towards non-Muslims, contrasting starkly with Indonesia's inclusive approach. This contradiction raises questions about mutual understanding and respect between the two nations.

Conclusion

While it is essential to acknowledge and address the specific issues between Indonesia and Malaysia, it is equally important to recognize the underlying bond and shared values that continue to bind these nations together. The opinions and sentiments of individuals are diverse, and blanket statements about one nationality disliking another do little to foster understanding and constructive dialogue. Let us strive for nuance and mutual respect as we navigate our shared history and evolving relations.