Navigating the Clichés: Examining the Common Pitfalls in Police Procedural TV Shows

As police procedural TV shows continue to captivate audiences, it's important to recognize the common clichés that can detract from the storytelling. This article explores some of the worst clichés found in this genre and how they can impact the depth and realism of the narratives.

The Lone Wolf Detective

The lone wolf detective is a prevalent trope in police procedural TV shows, often depicted as a brilliant but troubled individual who defies established protocols. However, this portrayal can feel unrealistic as modern policing relies heavily on teamwork and collaboration. The overemphasis on a single individual's brilliance and independent nature can diminish the significance of the support systems and the teamwork that are vital in real police work.

The By-the-Book Character

Conversely, there is a counterbalance to the lone wolf through the by-the-book character who strictly adheres to rules and procedures. While this dynamic can be interesting, it often becomes predictable and formulaic, leading to a kind of choose your favorite trope narrative. These characters are valuable for their adherence to process, but the tension between them and the lone wolf can feel too contrived and less nuanced in real-world scenarios.

Overly Dramatic Confessions

The overly dramatic confession is another cliche that can detract from the realism of the show. Suspects often confess in highly theatrical and choreographed ways, which can feel exaggerated compared to the reality of police interrogations. In real-life interrogations, the process is typically more nuanced and methodical, often involving psychological manipulation and reading body language, rather than the dramatic breakdowns seen on television.

Laboratory Myths and Muggles

The show possesses laboratory myths and muggles, referring to characters who can instantly access information with unrealistic technology. This includes the ability to hack into systems or magically retrieve any piece of information on command. This portrayal oversimplifies the complexities of police work and forensic science, reducing the intricate processes that real detectives must follow to gather evidence and solve cases.

Instant DNA Results

The idea of instant DNA results is another cliche that can undermine the realism of police procedural shows. In reality, DNA analysis can take days or weeks to complete, and rushing the process can lead to inaccuracies and misinterpretations. This cliche often leads to unrealistic plot resolutions where cases are solved in a matter of hours, which fails to reflect the actual time and effort required in real-world investigations.

Secretly Corrupt Authority Figures

The secretly corrupt authority figure is a common plot device in police procedurals, often leading to unnecessary tension within the department. While such characters can add excitement and drama to a show, their presence can overshadow the integrity of the force and the collaborative nature of real police work. Such tropes can dilute the gravity of the police force's mission and the importance of trust and cooperation among colleagues.

Plot Twists and Improbable Clues

Plot twists and improbable clues are favored by many writers for their ability to keep the audience on the edge of their seats. However, these elements often feel contrived and can undermine the buildup of the story. The revelation of vital evidence or information just in time to solve a case can feel artificial, devoid of the hard work and strategic thinking that genuine detectives must apply. This can make the story feel less authentic and more like a puzzle rather than a complex human endeavor.

The Sympathetic Villain

The portrayal of sympathetic villains with complex backstories can add depth to the narrative, but it can also overshadow the gravity of their crimes. While understanding the underlying motivations of a criminal can be illuminating, it is crucial to balance these portrayals with the seriousness of their actions. Real-world criminals often have a myriad of factors contributing to their behavior, and showcasing this complexity can make the narratives both more nuanced and more impactful.

While these clichés can be entertaining when used sparingly, their overuse can lead to predictability and a lack of depth in police procedural storytelling. By recognizing and avoiding these tropes, writers can create more authentic, engaging, and realistic narratives that resonate with their audience.