Military Terms in Star Trek: The Next Generation - Inaccurate Hollywoodization or Authentic Naval Practices?

In the television series Star Trek: The Next Generation, Commander Picard, the captain of the starship Enterprise, was known for using the phrase 'Make it so' in a manner that occasionally raised eyebrows. The use of this phrase, originally a naval tradition, has become part of the cultural zeitgeist, but it is often misinterpreted and inaccurately used in popular media. This article aims to clarify the proper usage of such terms and explore their presence and impact in one of the most beloved science fiction series.

The Proper Usage of 'Make It So'

In the US Navy, a critical part of bridge procedure involves precise timekeeping, ensuring that crew members are aware of the current time down to the second. At 2000 hours, or 8 PM, a report is made to the captain or command duty officer, followed by the response 'Make it so.' This phrase, according to Naval Tradition and Usage, is specifically used when a time-keeping report is made, as it pertains to the accurate maintenance of the ship's chronometers. In a mechanized world, ensuring the accuracy of time is paramount for navigation and safety.

Other Examples of Hollywood Misrepresentation

Lock and Load

Another commonly misused term in popular media is 'lock and load.' This phrase is particularly associated with the M1 Garand rifle, and it involves pulling the bolt back until it locks open, inserting an 8-round en bloc clip into the magazine, and ensuring the weapon is loaded and ready. This phrase is often incorrectly used as a general command to prepare for combat, neglecting the specific context of the M1 Garand rifle. The term 'locked and loaded' is even more confusing, as it may suggest that the weapon is somehow 'mashed' together, which is incorrect.

Cocked and Locked

The phrase 'cocked and locked' is often used to describe a firearm being in a ready state, but the true meaning is specific to the M1911.1911 pistol requires the user to slide the bolt to the rear, chamber a round, cock the hammer, and engage the safety lock. In this configuration, the weapon is indeed 'cocked and locked'—meaning it cannot go off unintentionally. Misusing this term can lead to misunderstandings and possible safety hazards.

Commander Picard's Usage of 'Make It So'

However, the misuse and overuse of 'Make it so' in Star Trek: The Next Generation has become a focal point of debate among fans and military historians alike. In the series, Captain Jean-Luc Picard frequently uses this phrase, often in a manner that has led some to question its authenticity. According to Star Trek: The Official Starship Files, Picard's usage may be a deliberate choice to emphasize his command and authority or simply a stylistic choice that became iconic throughout the series.

The Case of Riker's Departure

The series' portrayal of Picard often takes liberties for dramatic effect. For instance, when William Riker left the Enterprise due to the severe expletive-laden language of Commander Picard, the show’s writers may have emphasized the outrageousness of Picard's language to drive the narrative. The reality, however, is that Picard was not known for his foul-mouthed behavior. In the original Star Trek series, Captain Kirk rarely used profanity, and the concept of profanity as a cultural norm did not exist in the 23rd and 24th centuries portrayed in the show.

Impact on Other Characters

Other characters in the series, such as Geordi La Forge, Dr. Beverly Crusher, Worf, William Riker, and even Chief Miles O'Brien, have also been depicted using profanity and foul language. However, it is important to note that the frequency and intensity of such language were often exaggerated for story continuity and viewer appeal. The overuse of profanity, as depicted in the series, may not align with the cultural norms and standards of the United Federation of Planets, a society portrayed as advanced and progressive.

Conclusion

The term 'Make it so' in Star Trek: The Next Generation is a prime example of how Hollywood may inaccurately represent real-world practices for dramatic effect. While the phrase holds significant meaning in naval traditions, its overuse in the series for emphasis and drama can lead to misconceptions. Similarly, terms like 'lock and load' and 'cocked and locked' have specific historical and military contexts that are often diluted for entertainment purposes. Understanding the context and origin of such terms can enrich one's appreciation of not only the show but also the real-world practices and traditions it draws from.

Ultimately, while Star Trek: The Next Generation has succeeded in entertaining audiences for decades, it is crucial to distinguish between the show's portrayal and the authenticity of its inspired terminology.