Merger of Two Worlds: A Hypothetical War Between Numenor and Westeros

This article delves into a speculative scenario where the ancient realms of Numenor and Westeros would engage in a hypothetical conflict. While these realms are immensely distant and culturally distinct, the comparison provides valuable insights into the military and strategic prowess of both civilizations.

Background and Setting

Numenor, a former great nation from The Lord of the Rings universe, existed on Middle-earth, a vast and mystical land. Meanwhile, Westeros, the world of A Song of Ice and Fire, is situated on a far-off continent. The inhabitants of these realms would be quite surprised to even know of each other's existence, for they are thousands of years apart and separated by vast oceans.

Strengths and Weaknesses of Westeros

Westeros, governed by the Seven Kingdoms, is a highly diverse and complex society. With a maximum troop count of 50,000 to 100,000, depending on various alliances and seasons, Westeros is capable of fielding decent-sized armies. However, it suffers from significant drawbacks, including frequent in-fighting among nobles, weak leadership, and inexperienced commanders.

Military Forces of Westeros

Westeros also boasts a formidable naval force, with over 1,000 ships. While this naval capability is formidable against local threats, its effectiveness against a trans-oceanic power like Numenor is questionable.

Dragons and Magic

The presence of dragons poses a significant threat to any opposing force. If Westeros were to use its dragons, they would likely encounter formidable resistance. Additionally, the potential for the intervention of powerful entities such as the Iスターリ (Istari) or the ancient dragon Smaug could dramatically alter the course of any conflict.

Military Forces of Numenor

Numenor, on the other hand, represents humanity at its zenith, possessing unparalleled military and technological prowess. At its peak, Numenor could field an army of over 200,000 to 300,000 elite warriors, comparable to the strength of Gil-Galad, an extremely powerful elven hero.

Technological Advancements and Naval Power

Numenor's technological achievements are unparalleled, with structures like Orthanc and Minas Tirith standing as testaments to their power and resilience. The Numenorean navy, the largest in history, numbered over 10,000 vessels. Even during its most difficult times, Gondor faced immense challenges without the nearly invincible Numenorean forces.

The Impact of Sauron

In cases where Sauron, the dark lord, is involved, Numenor could gain significant advantages. Sauron's ability to command a vast array of orcish and otherworldly forces could cripple opposing armies. The Numenoreans, with their vast resources and elite training, would be nearly invincible.

Ancient Legends and Warnings

Myths and legends within Middle-earth suggest that an alliance between Numenor and forces such as those led by Sauron would render Westeros virtually defenseless. While the timelines of Numenor and Westeros do not align, the hypothetical scenario remains an intriguing subject of speculation and discussion among fans of both series.

Overall, Numenor's superiority in military might, technological prowess, and strategic acumen makes it almost invincible against any force, whether from within Middle-earth or beyond. Westeros, despite its dragons and natural advantages, would be severely outmatched in such a confrontation.