Lupin vs. Sherlock Holmes: Which Intelligent Enigma Outsmarts the Other?

The world of fictional intelligence is replete with mind-bending characters who challenge and outthink each other. Two such characters are Arsène Lupin and Sherlock Holmes. Unlike Sherlock Holmes, who is often portrayed as the central and most-venerated detective, Arsène Lupin has his own fan base who idolize his cunning, charm, and ability to thwart other intelligent forces. This article delves into their fascinating rivalry, as depicted in the stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle's original agent, Maurice Leblanc.

A Historical Background: Lupin and Holmes’ First Clash

Back in 1906, Maurice Leblanc, the creator of Arsène Lupin, wrote a story that included an older Sherlock Holmes. This was a pivotal moment in the fictional world, as breathing life into Holmes brought a different dynamic to the narrative. However, Arthur Conan Doyle's agent demanded that Leblanc stop using the name "Holmes" to avoid potential lawsuits from Doyle's representatives. This particular story, titled "Sherlock Holmes Arrives Too Late," served as the starting point of a rivalry that would be marked with intelligence showdowns.

Lupin and Holmes as Stand-ins for Each Other

In several stories, Herlock Sholmes and his sidekick John Wilson became clear stand-ins for Holmes and Watson, demonstrating a parallel universe where the roles and relationships shift. In these works, Lupin respects Sholmes but does not directly oppose him. Instead, Lupin often outwits Sholmes or at least gives a close run for his money, which is a testament to Leblanc's clever storytelling.

The Cleverness of Arsène Lupin

As we explore stories where Arsène Lupin faces off against Herlock Sholmes, it becomes evident that Lupin is constantly engaged in mental battles. One of the most intriguing aspects of Lupin's character is his ability to outthink his opponents. In two of these stories, Leblanc narrates Lupin's clever maneuvers that make Sholmes seem like he arrived "too late."

Conclusion: A Matter of Personal Preference

While personal preferences in fiction are highly subjective, it is my opinion that both characters possess their unique brand of intelligence. If you hold Arsène Lupin in high regard, you will find that his ingenuity and charm make him the most formidable adversary. Conversely, if you are a die-hard fan of Sherlock Holmes, you cannot deny Holmes's brilliance and relentless pursuit of justice.

However, it is important to remember that the world of fiction is vast and diverse, allowing every reader to find their own heroes and villains. So, perhaps it's best to simply enjoy the narrative and let each character shine on their own merits!

N.B.: For those interested in exploring these stories further, consider reading Arsène Lupin contre Herlock Sholmès.