Looper Avengers Endgame or Tenet: Which Movie Had the Most Ridiculous Logic in Time Travel?

When it comes to time travel, filmmakers often attempt to weave complex and intricate plots that challenge the audience's understanding of the Fourth Dimension. Among these, Tenet, Avengers: Endgame, and Looper stand out for their attempts to explain the mechanics of time travel. However, some might argue that these films have logical inconsistencies that are hard to stomach. Let's explore the most ridiculous logical issues in these sci-fi blockbusters.

1st: Tenet - The Bullet and Gold Paradox

Tenet, despite its complexity and clever plot, suffers from absurd logical fallacies. The concept of "backwards" time and objects is intriguing but becomes convoluted when put into practice. For instance, how did Sator use the buried gold if it was "backwards" gold and he was buried in the future? This raises a series of questions that defy rational explanation:

How can you shoot someone with a backwards gun? Do you have to wait for them to walk past a bullet hole? What happens if a forward person shoots a backwards person with a forward gun? Is it the gun or the bullet that matters in the first place?

The reliance on "bootstrapping" futures, which doesn't align well with the narrative, adds another layer of confusion. These logical inconsistencies make the film's intentions harder to follow, resulting in a less satisfying viewing experience.

2nd: Avengers Endgame - Unrestricted Time Travel

Avengers: Endgame attempts to establish a consistent logic around time travel, only to deviate from it in the end. The "explaining time travel" sequence sets the stage for a coherent understanding, but it quickly breaks down:

The introduction of an unlimited potential to bring people and items back from the dead introduces a new level of complexity and chaos. What happens when this genie is let out of the bottle? The narrative undermines previous lessons about time travel, making the plot less cohesive and creating a sense of dissonance for the audience.

While these flaws may be minor compared to Tenet, the sheer abundance of inconsistent elements detracts from the overall storytelling. It is still a well-loved and widely acclaimed film, but its logical fallacies cannot be overlooked.

3rd: Looper - A Narrative Pass

Looper, on the other hand, gets an unexpected pass due to its carefully woven narrative. The film's logic is consistent and serves the drama, which makes the audience suspend disbelief in a more satisfying manner:

The protagonists' understanding of the time loop concept fits seamlessly into the story. From their perspective, time travel makes logical sense and drives the plot forward effectively. The narrative is far more relatable, as it aligns with the characters' experiences and motivations.

While the mechanics of time travel in Looper might not be intrinsically more credible, the overall storyline and character development provide a more cohesive and emotionally resonant experience for the audience.

Conclusion

In the quest to create sophisticated and intriguing time travel narratives, Tenet and Avengers: Endgame seem to trip up the most when it comes to logical consistency. Each film introduces unique complexities that, while ambitious, fail to synchronize seamlessly. In contrast, Looper excels by maintaining a logical framework that enhances the dramatic narrative, providing a more compelling experience for the audience.