Lactating Women and the Survival of Jon Snow: A Critical Analysis

In the world of A Song of Ice and Fire and its adaptation A Game of Thrones, the survival of Jon Snow in the Doe’s Eye childbirth at the Tower of Joy has been a topic of much speculation. This article delves into the role of lactating women, particularly Wylla, in ensuring Jon's survival.

Background: The Doe's Eye

The decisive moment of Jon Snow's life, marked by the events surrounding the Doe's Eye, is a crucial point in the narrative. In the tale, Jon is delivered in a life-threatening childbirth, with only goats' milk and butter being referenced as alternatives to breast milk.

The Role of Lactating Women

It is strongly implied that a lactating woman was indeed present to ensure Jon's survival. This raises questions about the viability of other options like goats' milk and butter, as well as the involvement of Wylla, Lyanna Stark's midwife and servant, who also acted as Jon's first wetnurse.

Given that the Kingsguard, along with Ned and Howland, were among the few survivors found with Lyanna's body, it is evident that other individuals were present at the Tower of Joy. Ned's reference to "they" implies the presence of multiple people, aside from himself and Howland. Logical conclusions point to Wylla's involvement, as it would be improbable for a midwife and wetnurse to be absent during such a critical event.

Lactating Women in the Tower of Joy

The presence of a lactating woman is further supported by the visual evidence in the show. At least one female servant is visibly present during the sequence of events at the Tower of Joy, indicating the importance of continuous care and feeding for Jon.

The Significance of Wylla

Wylla, Ned’s “official” mother for Jon, was a significant figure in the narrative. She was at Starfall at the time of the Doe's Eye, as revealed by Ned’s reference to Wylla as Jon’s “milk brother” and her role in feeding both Ned and Jon. This suggests that Wylla was involved in creating the story of Jon’s parentage, which adds an element of complexity to her role.

Wylla’s involvement makes more sense if she was present at the Tower of Joy, providing crucial care for Jon. Her presence would allow her to bond with the child and continue her role in nourishing him. The sequence of events, including the return of Wylla to Starfall with Ned and Jon, and her subsequent stay at Starfall when transferring Jon to the North, aligns with her significant role in his early life.

Conclusion

The role of lactating women, particularly the presence of Wylla, in the survival and upbringing of Jon Snow is a critical aspect of the narrative. The alternative options of goats' milk and butter, while recognized as possibilities, do not provide the same level of comfort and health benefits as human breast milk. The involvement of Wylla in both the immediate and subsequent care of Jon, including her role in his early life and the development of the story of Jon’s parentage, underscores her importance in this pivotal moment of the narrative.

Understanding the significance of lactating women in critical events not only enhances our appreciation of the story but also enriches the understanding of the complex familial and narrative dynamics at play in A Game of Thrones and A Song of Ice and Fire.