La La Land vs Moonlight: A Critical Comparison

Introduction

The year 2016 was marked by two notable films that captured the hearts and minds of audiences worldwide: La La Land and Moonlight. Despite the accolades they both received, the award for Best Picture went to Moonlight, which many critics and fans believe was the less deserving of the two. This article delves into a detailed comparison, examining their narratives, visual and audio appeal, and broader implications.

Visual and Audio Appeal

La La Land emerged as the more visually stunning film. Its elaborate choreography, enchanting dance numbers, and rich musical score captured the imagination and delighted the audience. The film's musical and dance sequences are finely crafted, creating a captivating experience that resonates with both visual and auditory senses.

On the other hand, Moonlight, while visually compelling, is described as more edgy and raw. The film's narrative is stripped back, focusing on the lives of its characters in a gritty, realistic manner. While Moonlight has its fair share of striking imagery and poignant scenes, the overall production design and musical elements do not reach the same level of grandeur as those in La La Land.

Narrative Depth and Substance

La La Land boasts a more tightly woven narrative that balances action, emotion, and romance. The characters are well-developed, and the story progresses through a series of well-executed scenes that feel both natural and compelling. The film's love story is relatable and beautifully orchestrated, making it a truly engaging watch.

Moonlight, while receiving mixed reviews and holding a strong emotional impact, is often criticized for its non-linear storytelling and abrupt endings. The film's focus on a single character's journey over a decade creates a powerful, yet sometimes disjointed, narrative. The story's unfolding is less organic, and certain plot points feel rushed or left unexplained, such as the character's sexuality and the nature of his relationship.

Critique of Moonlight

While Moonlight is widely praised for its emotional depth and powerful performances, several issues are highlighted in its structure and theme. Critics argue that the film lacks a cohesive narrative and fails to provide a satisfying resolution. For example, the depiction of gay characters is criticized for being stereotypical and unrealistic. The portrayal of a closeted gay man's relationship with another man is seen as problematic, as it exoticizes the gay experience and oversimplifies the complexities of sexual orientation.

Additionally, some scenes in Moonlight are deemed poorly executed, such as the hazing sequence and the rushed meetings between the main characters. These elements detract from the film's overall narrative and create an uneven viewing experience. The relationship between Chiron and Kevin, in particular, is seen as lacking in depth and tension, which is crucial for a film dealing with such significant themes.

Comparison and Conclusion

While both films are highly regarded and offer unique perspectives on the human experience, La La Land stands out as the superior film in most aspects. Its intricate storyline, charismatic performances, and impeccable production values make it a masterpiece. The film balances aesthetics and storytelling, creating a truly immersive and unforgettable experience.

Moonlight, however, is a commendable piece of cinema that delves deeply into the lived experiences of its characters. Although it may not be as visually and audibly stunning as La La Land, its raw and authentic portrayal of its subjects makes a compelling case for its artistic merit. The controversy surrounding which film should have won the Best Picture award highlights the inherent subjectivity and personal biases in film criticism.

In conclusion, while both films have their merits, La La Land's excellence in narrative, visual appeal, and emotional depth solidifies its position as the superior film of the two.